3 ms·
Substituting "power" for "freedom" doesn't really change anything. You can certainly argue that a software distributor exerts power on a user when they don't pr
by baddox 13y ago
Substituting "power" for "freedom" doesn't really change anything. You can certainly argue that a software distributor exerts power on a user when they don't provide source code, but you can just as easily argue that a software distributor exerts power on a user when they provide the source code but don't allow derivative works to be distributed without source code.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoThe slavery analogy is interesting because it's something that we all agree is unequivocally wrong. People sometimes can't wrap their heads around the GPL because not everyone agrees that e.g. not providing source code is unequivocally wrong, but that's the stance the GPL takes. Imagine a world where slavery isn't prohibited by law, and that isn't going to change, but we still want to discourage it as much as possible. So someone comes up with the idea for a "license" to grant to current slaves: You can have your freedom, with the one restriction that you can't work with anyone who owns slaves unless they free them all and attach the same restriction. The idea being to create a large population of former slaves who have been freed with that condition, so that you create an economic environment in which owning slaves is discouraged, because anyone who continues to own slaves can no longer do business with an economically important population of former slaves. Obviously you get the objection that you're restricting the freedom of the former slaves. The freed slaves would be individually better off if they could work with whoever they wanted, especially if there is a nontrivial population of slave owners who continue to refuse to accept that condition and might otherwise do business with them, but then you lose all the incentive for the existing slave owners to free their slaves which on the whole would result in a net reduction in freedom.
- spacelizard 13y agoNo, that doesn't follow. Giving certain users the ability to distribute derivative works to other users but yet say no when one of them asks for the source code presents the same misappropriation of power as if the author of the original work was doing it. The point of copyleft and the GPL is that no groups or individuals should be able to exert power over anybody else using the software in question.