5 ms·
I kind of got the impression that Weev getting sent up for identity fraud was a lot like Al Capone getting it for tax evasion. Which is to say, he was a sadisti
by PhasmaFelis 13y ago
I kind of got the impression that Weev getting sent up for identity fraud was a lot like Al Capone getting it for tax evasion. Which is to say, he was a sadistic monster of a troll who delighted in ruining people's lives, but he was cunning enough to never quite cross the criminal-harassment line with anyone brave enough to press charges, so they got him on this instead.
It's a rotten precedent, and I can't really blame anyone for opposing it on principle, but let's do remember that Weev himself is not any kind of hero.
- eridius 13y agoAlso don't forget that Weev was considering selling the info he got, before he decided to be lazy and just tell the world. So not only is he a massive troll, but his motives for the "hack" were also less than saintly.
- andrewcooke 13y agoglad i haven't been jailed for things i've considered. i'd be down for murdering a lot of commentators on hn...
- bigiain 13y ago<devil's advocate>If you "consider" stealing thousands of credit card numbers, break into a business and collect all the required data, then get lazy before you get around to incurring fraudulent charges and just boast about it instead, perhaps you _do_ deserve jail time</devil's advocate> weev fucked up - and he _knew_ he was "fucking up" when he went from "finding a vulnerability" to "automatically exploiting that vulnerability to collect as much data as he could". Felten, Blaze, Schneier, Kaminsky - they would all have tried incrementing the get parameter - when it worked they would all have tried a bunch more times to confirm their assumptions, none of them would expect to get away with subsequent wholesale download of AT&T's customer data. Neither should weev.
- pyre 13y agoIIRC, all he would have been selling is email addresses that are known to belong to iPad owners with AT&T as a provider. I don't recall that he had any credit card info.
- bigiain 13y agoYeah sure. That's what the devil's advocate tags were about. I was arguing reductio-ad-absurdum - for some crimes, half carried through preparations should be punishable even if the intended "end crime" never got carried out. I'm not suggesting weev was after credit cards or intending to commit fraud. But I stand by me second para - that Kaminsky or Blaze wouldn't have downloaded the entire database after confirming the vulnerability works - and weev should have known he was "doing something wrong" when he chose to. I agree that AT&T (and the prosecutors here) are _seriously_ overreacting, but weev was a fool if he didn't expect _any_ adverse reaction.
- pyre 13y agoThe mother that drove her daughters' friend/rival to suicide via fake MySpace profiles should have known that what she was doing was wrong, but a conviction for her on the grounds that using a fake name violated MySpace's Terms of Service, and is therefore 'hacking' under the CFAA is just bad law. Making bad law to punish someone that was doing something 'bad' is a net-loss to society, not a net-win
- bigiain 13y agoAgreed. This stinks to me of AT&T and their legal team trying to make them look like "the victim" - where in truth their subscribers are he aggrieved parties here and AT&T are as much in the wrong from he subscribers point of view as weev is.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jfb 13y agoRegardless, it seems that they're railroading a guilty person.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoIs that supposed to make it OK? If the man is actually guilty of a crime, convict him of that crime. If not, don't. What you're saying is that we should convict innocent people of crimes they haven't committed because we don't like them. Do you not see the problem with that?
- jfb 13y agoThat's what the term "railroaded" means in this context: that a person is not being subject to due process.
- sneak 13y agoYou can, in fact, forget that. We should judge people to be criminals or not based on their actions, not their daydreams. Also, how is it lazy to create a media shitstorm and get your house raided versus making some free money quickly and quietly? Are you really trying to frame his turning down free money as the MORE disdainful choice?!
- ceol 13y agoIt is in fact illegal to "daydream" (i.e. make solid plans) about doing certain crimes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conspiracy_(crime) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conspiracy_(crime)
- moocowduckquack 13y agoTo try and define the term "daydream" as being equivalent to "make solid plans" so that you can equate daydreaming with criminal conspiracy is some of the most tortuous logic I have seen in a while. Have you ever thought of a job as a government press secretary? You'd fit right in.
- ceol 13y agoTrying to define "talking to your friends about how you're going to sell stolen information" as being equivalent to "daydream" is the tortuous logic I was responding to. Please read the entire thread and not just comments you don't agree with.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI did read the whole thread and I just read the published transcripts. He does not say that he is going to sell stolen information. He does remark on irc that the information is valuable and could be sold or used for a phishing operation, but that is an observation of reality, and can not be taken as a statement of intent without some other evidence showing that he was likely to pursue that course of action, and given that he then handed the list to gawker it would seem that this was not his intent, though the possibility had obviously crossed his mind. To consider the possibility of indulging in criminal behaviour is not the same as planning to do so.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoThat doesn't tell us the motives for the hack, just that he is possibly being honest about what ran through his head after finding something valuable.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoIt's what's called a trumped-up charge, or Kangaroo Court. This kind of thing happens to unsympathetic defendants like Weev first. Then later it can happen to anyone who gets in the way.
- walid 13y ago+1
- kaoD 13y ago> he was a sadistic monster of a troll who delighted in ruining people's lives Could you elaborate?
- JoshTriplett 13y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weev#Trolling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weev#Trolling makes it quite clear.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoSure. First, go read this: http://www.gossamer-threads.com/lists/fulldisc/full-disclosure/52577 http://www.gossamer-threads.com/lists/fulldisc/full-disclosu... djfooroach/Memphis Two is Weev, as per page five of this New York Times article. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/03/magazine/03trolls-t.html http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/03/magazine/03trolls-t.html An excerpt: Over a candlelit dinner of tuna sashimi, Weev asked if I would attribute his comments to Memphis Two, the handle he used to troll Kathy Sierra, a blogger. Inspired by her touchy response to online commenters, Weev said he “dropped docs” on Sierra, posting a fabricated narrative of her career alongside her real Social Security number and address. This was part of a larger trolling campaign against Sierra, one that culminated in death threats. Weev says he has access to hundreds of thousands of Social Security numbers. About a month later, he sent me mine. In 2007, Kathy Sierra was the target of an avalanche of death and rape threats that drove her out of tech and public life entirely. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathy_Sierra#Harassment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathy_Sierra#Harassment Nobody seems to be quite certain why, except that it may have had to do with a blog post defending people's right to delete comments from their own blogs. Sierra said, "I have cancelled all speaking engagements. I am afraid to leave my yard, I will never feel the same. I will never be the same." Weev claims credit for this. He's proud of it. There's plenty more out there, if you care to trace through Weev's many aliases. He was never shy about how much he loved brutalizing people. “I hack, I ruin, I make piles of money,” he boasted. “I make people afraid for their lives.” --The New York Times again. Anything else you need to know?
- tomjen3 13y agoOkay that does it, he needs to be locked up. What an utter little shit.
- cgag 13y agoI blame anyone for not opposing it on principle. If you're ok with some trumped up bullshit because you don't like the person, fuck you (not aimed at your personally).
- darkchasma 13y agoI'm okay with it. Weev is the type of guy I wish was behind bars. He's a stain with no redeeming qualities that I can tell. He takes a lot of joy in causing people pain, and many peoples lives are better with him behind bars. So I don't really care if it's for wire fraud or tax evasion.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- moocowduckquack 13y agoUnpleasantness is not a crime. Which judging from your post is probably something you should be thankful for.
- ceol 13y agoWhat weev did crossed many times into criminal territory. He harassed a lot of people in ways that made it either hard or unlikely to press charges. Seriously, save the reaching argument for people who aren't complete scumbags.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoSo prosecute him for the shit that deserved prosecution and leave the CFAA out of it.
- mpyne 13y agoWell someday we'll get CFAA reform... but even then I'm convinced that weev in particular would still have run afoul of it in this case (though presumably a misdemeanor variant of it). Security researchers in general wouldn't run afoul of even the current version IMO, though it's certainly prudent for security researches to re-emphasize how key some of those techniques are for them, so that we don't end up in a surreal situation where even altering a URL, cookie, etc. one time would subject one to conviction under CFAA.
- throwaway1234hi 13y agoyes. weev would run botnets, send spam for money, break into computers, and once or twice egged people to their deaths. fortunately for him, the friends of his that would remember this (generally) don't live long, so he gets to re-invent himself every few years. I guess this time he's the savior of the internet, which is darkly ironic, considering he owned about half of the people who filed for this brief at one point or another.