12 ms·
> They have always been about freedom first and software second, and Stallman has many times stated that he'd rather a program be used less if it results in mor
by baddox 13y ago
> They have always been about freedom first and software second, and Stallman has many times stated that he'd rather a program be used less if it results in more freedom, than vice versa.
I think I disagree with your interpretation, but I think my disagreement hinges on a semantic disagreement about the word "freedom." To me, the GPL is a legal limitation on freedom. It prohibits certain use cases, like distributing that software without its source code. To me, a piece of software is "more free" if its source code is available, but people are still able to do literally anything they want with the source code, including distributing binaries without providing access to the source code. I think the point of the GPL is to utilize the copyright system to ensure access to source code for everyone, not to simply increase freedom.
The slavery quip doesn't really make sense, because in that analogy the source code is the slave. So unless we're talking about increasing freedom for source code (which is a strange notion, since most source code is not conscious) rather than increasing freedom for people, my disagreement still applies. The reason forbidding slavery is not generally considered a decrease in freedom is that both slave owners and slaves are people.
- spacelizard 13y agoThe GPL does not limit freedom, it only limits power. Distributing a binary to a user while denying them the source code, while not strictly a malicious act, is an attack on the user's freedom because it puts the user at a position where the author hold power over him/her. The author allows himself/herself to freely study and modify the program in its preferred format (the source code), but he/she has intentionally made it impossible for the user to do this. Copyleft is about authors willingly removing the powers granted to them by copyright and "redistributing" them so that all users are granted freedom. It's worth noting that the GPL does not say you have to give out source code all the time, you just have to give it out when people ask for it, and you have to make the offer to give it out clear. So the actual issue that you believe is "a limitation on freedom" is the lack of the ability to say no when someone asks for the source code, despite that they have already been distributed a binary. However, there are no practical reasons to do this that don't involve intentionally keeping secrets from people, or intentionally making studying and modification of the program difficult.
- pbsdp 13y agoI'm a user, and I want to use your library in my product. The GPL limits my freedom.
- spacelizard 13y agoYour choice of not wanting to accept the GPL doesn't limit your freedom, you had the choice to accept it and you declined. The fact that the software is copyrighted in the first place is the only thing that could be potentially limiting your freedom, and the GPL cannot do anything about that.
- baddox 13y agoCopyrights are not contracts. They do not have to be agreed upon for them to be legally enforceable.
- pbsdp 13y agoUsers of proprietary software have the choice and can decline, too. Since users dont need it to protect their freedom, why is the GPL necessary if not to restrict freedom?
- gillianseed 13y agoBecause what it actually protects is rights, rights of the end user. You of course know this, but you instead choose to endlessly harp on the meaning of the word 'freedom'. Licencing your code under GPL grants the recipient of any binary in which your code is included a specific set of rights. These rights include the right to the source code should the recipient want it. This particular right makes GPL very interesting for many developers as they can release code, and then as recipients of modifications of that code, get access to those modifications in source code form and thus gain improvements to their original code.
- pbsdp 13y agoIf those users don't want to use code that isn't released liberally, they don't have to. So what are you actually securing for them? It's not freedom, they already have the freedom to not use proprietary software.
- drcube 13y ago>I think the point of the GPL is to utilize the copyright system to ensure access to source code for everyone, not to simply increase freedom. According to many, including the FSF, GNU, Stallman and myself, increasing access to the source code for everyone is increasing freedom. In fact, it's freedom number 1. "The freedom to study how the program works, and change it to make it do what you wish." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Freedoms_%28software%29#Definition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Freedoms_%28software%29#D... > The slavery quip doesn't really make sense, because in that analogy the source code is the slave. No, it's about freedom for people in both cases. The lack of source code would be analogous to the chains of slavery. Not equivalent, mind you, but analogous. A software user is less free when he or she cannot inspect or modify the software that runs on their machine.
- pbsdp 13y ago> According to many, including the FSF, GNU, Stallman and myself, increasing access to the source code for everyone is increasing freedom. Once released freely, the source code never stops being free, so I don't really know what they're talking about in terms of "freedom". MIT licensed code is almost infinitely free, it will never stop being free, and nobody can take it away from you. It seems to me that they're interested in forcing other people's source code to be free.
- icebraining 13y agoWhen some corporation sells you some proprietary software, the consumer has the FREEDOM to choose if he wants to fork over his cash in exchange for it. When the proprietary developer encounters some piece of GPL software, he's being forced to comply with it, even if it's still his own decision whether or not to incorporate the code in his project. Ah, language. (TL;DR: nobody is forcing anyone to accept the GPL. The GPL offers you a deal - passing forward the four freedoms is just the price of using the library.)
- pbsdp 13y agoThe GPL does offer a deal, but its dishonest to call it 'freedom'.
- dllthomas 13y agoThe goal of the GPL is to protect the freedom of users of software. The freedom it restricts is not generally relevant to those just trying to use the software, only to those who want to pass on changes in ways that restrict the freedom of their users.
- mcguire 13y ago"To me, a piece of software is "more free" if its source code is available, but people are still able to do literally anything they want with the source code, including distributing binaries without providing access to the source code." Yes, because AIX is more free, because Solaris is more free, because Irix and HP-UX and a small plethora of other operating systems are more free. That whole "more free" idea? It's not theory. It's history. It didn't work. That "legal limitation on freedom" came about for a specific reason: because software released under things like the BSD license that were "more free" were taken, modified, and made proprietary. All of those operating systems essentially started as BSD Unix; the last time I saw any of the AIX source code, it had BSD copyright notices all over it. (Including on parts that clearly weren't BSD, like the journaled file system. Weird.) That works fine, if you are a member of Berkeley's CSRG and thus the best programmer in the world. Those people touching your can't improve it; the best they can do is tarnish your brilliance. I am not the best programmer in the world, so I'm not terribly impressed with your interpretation.
- shizzy0 13y ago> The slavery quip doesn't really make sense, because in that analogy the source code is the slave. Wrong. Your users who don't have the same power to make changes as you do are the slaves in the analogy, not the source code. I sum it up thusly: BSD is about freedom for the developers; GPL is about freedom for the users. I work professionally as a software developer, but I use far more software than I develop.