5 ms·
> The ROM scene has always been a grey (verging on black) area when it comes to IP Speak for yourself. There are two scenes: The binary modder scene, where pe
by josteink 13y ago
> The ROM scene has always been a grey (verging on black) area when it comes to IP
Speak for yourself.
There are two scenes: The binary modder scene, where people retro-fit vendor-created and provided firmware-images with their own modifications. Commonly referred to as "Photoshop ROMs". This scene is clearly grey at best.
However, there is another scene: The one based on AOSP source and derivates of it. This scene lives on Github and similar places where open source is shared and reused freely, as intended.
This is driven by serious developers and focus is on doing things cleanly, properly and reliably.
Most successful and widely deployed ROMs (like Cyanogenmod) are based on this scene, and there is nothing grey or remotely shady about it.
- fulafel 13y agoThe open source subset of Android is not practically usable though. There aren't many (any?) devices that work usefully without a lot of proprietary bits.
- josteink 13y agoWhile true, you don't need to supply the actual copyrighted/licensed binaries across the internet. You can just supply a shell-script to extract them from the device, and its assumed that interested parties wanting to build the code has the device themselves. Feel free to call it a loophole, but I don't have a problem with that and definitely don't see it as something shady.
- stonemetal 13y agoTrue but from what I understand the images they put out have all the bits baked in. You literally just flash the new firmware onto the device. That means they are distributing bits they don't have licence to distribute.
- jlgreco 13y ago> The open source subset of Android is not practically usable though. And that will certainly remain the case if everybody ships their little backyard shed "rom" with proprietary bits included. If there is no demand for replacements, replacements will not be made.
- girvo 13y agoThat's why I mentioned the original XDA WinMo crowd, which I was a part of going back to 2006. They fall into the Binary Modder camp. :)
- stonemetal 13y agoCyanogenmod) are based on this scene, and there is nothing grey or remotely shady about it. So when Cyanogenmod was distributing the play store apps illegally there was nothing shady going on? It isn't like they suddenly decided to do the right thing, it was a C&D from Google that got them to stop. http://androidandme.com/2009/09/hacks/cyanogenmod-in-trouble/ http://androidandme.com/2009/09/hacks/cyanogenmod-in-trouble...
- venomsnake 13y agoCopyright and IP is such a mess that everything is "shady" for any entity if looked from the right (or wrong) angle or country. I don't think that there has been actual harm and malicious intent in the redistribution of the apps, just the fact that few people can afford the legal counsel fee to understand a licence.
- jlgreco 13y agoDistributing google apps was not shady from some carefully chosen "angle" or country, it was just plain shady.
- burntsushi 13y agoThat was four years ago. I think that's long enough to make a distinction between "they started out doing something they weren't supposed to" and "there's nothing shady about Cyanogenmod."
- freehunter 13y agoAnd yet people still point out that Volkswagen, Hugo Boss, and IBM worked with the Nazis and that Microsoft had been convicted of an illegal monopoly even though that all happened decades ago.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 13y ago