4 ms·
"The company relocated to East Texas...." This, I gather, was a mistake. While the East Texas "Rocket Docket" gained notoriety early on (and probably for some
by hga 13y ago
"The company relocated to East Texas...."
This, I gather, was a mistake.
While the East Texas "Rocket Docket" gained notoriety early on (and probably for some time), I've read recently that due to all the patent lawsuits they've been handling they've learned what it's all about and are no longer so plaintiff friendly. I suppose the bad press had an effect as well.
- eksith 13y agoBetter late than never, I suppose. I hope the Texans have enough pride in their community to pursue ethical processes toward business advancement. Patent trolls are business poison, but casual disregard for people is community poison. There's no reason ethics should get in the way of profits.
- Turing_Machine 13y agoPatent judges are federal judges, appointed by the President. The opinions of Texans at large are likely not very important.
- eksith 13y agoBut surely they pay some attention to community sentiment. There are some jerks behind the bench, I'm sure, but I like to think the majority are willing to serve their community objectively (or the legal system has no hope) and that would entail not screwing the very people he's appointed to serve. Government serves the people, not the other way around.
- protomyth 13y agoIf they are not from the area or a similar area and are climbing the federal court ladder, the majority seem to give not a care what the locals think. The locals are not the ones they need to impress.
- gruseom 13y agoBut a lot of these are jury trials, aren't they?
- hga 13y agoIncluding this one, which is why I brought up this point in the discussion. Here an East Texas jury looked at the facts etc. as portrayed by both sides, the law as instructed by the judge, and delivered the "right" verdict, which happened to be against the plaintiff.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sytelus 13y agoArticle says judgement was delivered by jury. This gives whole another angle to East Texas thing. Let's say you are town. Your major business is lawsuits, specifically, lawsuits from patent trolls. You are able to pay your bills because all these trolls descend in to your town feeling lucky and throw all these money to keep tour town prospered. How much jury selected from this town would be inclined to give judgments in plaintiff's favor?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Steko 13y agoA lot of it is probably that, simply on the merits, the average infringement case is a lot weaker than it was before the patent troll business model became popular.
- yardie 13y agoExactly. The district has built an industry around patent litigation, pro and con. I'm not sure where, but a patent lawyer made the comment on the forum. That if you're a defendant you want it to be East Texas. You can take your chances with 6 jurors who are familiar with patent law. Any other district you'd have 6 randomly selected people that probably don't know much on patents.