3 ms·
This whole thing is very confusing. There is over 17 gallons of carbon dioxide for every gallon of fuel burnt. Volume is a strange choice of measurement
by mikeyouse 13y ago
This whole thing is very confusing.
There is over 17 gallons of carbon dioxide for every gallon of fuel burnt.
Volume is a strange choice of measurement for a gas... The EIA[1] shows that about 8kg of CO2 are created for every gallon of gas that a car burns. We use a baseline stoichiometric consumption of about 1.8kg of CO2 per 1 kg of algal biomass.
They say these CO2ubes are good for 8-10 weeks, which if you average 200 miles per week, and 25mpg, you'd burn over 70 gallons of gas. This gas would've produced about 560kg of CO2. I can't imagine more than 1kg of biomass accumulating in this tip (especially since it's cantilevered at the furthest point from the exhaust clip) so you'd have used maybe 2kg of the CO2, reducing your consumption by 0.3%.
We are using the process of photosynthesis and applying it
to where carbon dioxide is being released. Since the process of
algae photosynthesis is not fast enough to accomodate for the
free flowing exhaust emissions, we have implemented a secondary
reactant into the device.
There's problem #2. Not only is photosynthesis not fast enough, it NEEDS SUNLIGHT. It doesn't use the "sun's energy" as is shown in that chart, it literally needs photons to excite the reaction centres.[2]
So they're not using photosynthesis at all. Apparently the tip arrives with a supply of NaOH inside, which reacts with CO2 in the exhaust stream and then is emitted out the tailpipe as carbonic acid. So why use algae at all?
Pending approval, users of the CO2ube will be able to drive in the
H.O.V. lane without meeting the occupancy minimum requirement [...]
Also pending approval, users of the CO2ube will receive an
additional tax credit from the EPA! [...] We have applied to give
our customers a tax credit (similar to the electric vehicle tax credit)
for using our technologies. Once that is approved, we plan to push
for regulation approval.
I'm shocked that they'd make these claims. There is virtually no chance they'll get HOV access. The 1st generation Chevy Volt, which made something like 65mpg equivalent didn't qualify for HOV access, why would this tech? They also expect that they're going to get Federal tax credits? Come on..
Also worth mentioning is that restricting the exhaust flow will also make the engine burn less efficiently, which will use more gasoline and create more CO2...
[1] http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=307&t=10 http://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.cfm?id=307&t=10
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthetic_reaction_centre http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthetic_reaction_centre
- avree 13y agoAgreed, the scientific claims are simply baffling. Science aside, the post comes across as a thinly-veiled attempt to brag about the founder. Press logos up top, followed by 'green buzzwords'. Then, a photo of the founders from the socialite party photo website "Guest of a Guest". Constant reference to a single accolade: their appearance on the Forbes 30 under 30 list, a list with no scientific review (or need for a demonstrable proof of concept) and an open nomination process. So strange why someone would do a campaign like this. It seems like the majority of the attention it's receiving is through Vanderbilt University's PR arm: http://news.vanderbilt.edu/tag/param-jaggi/ http://news.vanderbilt.edu/tag/param-jaggi/ (In fact, this story was submitted by a senior at Vanderbilt University! Surprise, suprise!)