2 ms·
That's way off base. You're not understanding my argument. Nobody said anything about magic. The point is how can you ever verify that two beings react exact
by dasil003 18y ago
That's way off base. You're not understanding my argument. Nobody said anything about magic.
The point is how can you ever verify that two beings react exactly the same to all stimuli? How are you determining "no measurable difference"? Setting aside the fact that silicon is measurably different from neural tissue, you still aren't any closer to answering the question "does the machine experience consciousness the same way I do as a result of its function?"
- rms 18y agoYou're talking about qualia. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualia Let's just pretend that we run all the arguments for and against qualia from that article against each other and declare us all losers in advance.
- trapper 18y agoYou can run them through all manner of tests. Sense tests, logic tests, math, philosophy, reading, every experience can be compared and contrasted. Now, assuming a large number of tests have been performed and there is a consensus they have no practical difference, why would you conclude that consciousness is not derived from brain structure?