5 ms·
Designer drugs show why a proper system of regulation is needed to replace the irresponsible "war" on drugs. But it's dangerous to think that the law cannot at
by rwmj 13y ago
Designer drugs show why a proper system of regulation is needed to replace the irresponsible "war" on drugs.
But it's dangerous to think that the law cannot attempt to make whole classes of chemicals illegal and so we don't need to worry about the war on drugs any more. The law can do that, and cause even more massive damage when it does so. Designer drugs are also likely to kill a whole lot of people, bolstering politicians who want to keep the status quo.
- aidos 13y agoIndeed. How about just making sure that the drugs people take are safe, of a high quality and available without feeding a criminal underbelly? Nah, that'd just be silly.
- freyr 13y agoThere are already pharmaceutical drugs for that , which are abused at epidemic levels in regions of the U.S. They're safe and of high quality, though they might still feed a criminal underbelly. Of course, people who get addicted to synthetic opiates often have their lives ravaged to the same degree as people who get addicted to regular old street heroin, despite the safety and quality of the drugs.
- betterunix 13y agoPharmaceutical drugs are too inaccessible to really remove the criminal element from recreational drugs. What is really needed is for regulated, high-quality drugs to be sold over the counter, with loads of warning labels, to any adult who wants them. It make sound crazy, but we already do it with two of the most dangerous drugs known to man: alcohol and tobacco. Nobody is claiming that there will not be issues with dependence or abuse of these drugs. The point is that people should not have to deal with dangerous criminals, nor should they be afraid of jail time for admitting their drug use.
- epochwolf 13y agoI don't think it's really fair to label tobacco as "dangerous". It's definitely toxic and it will shorten your lifespan by a number of years but it's not "dangerous". Tobacco doesn't make people do stupid things like alcohol does.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoYeah, but tobacco makes you smoke tobacco.
- matthiasl 13y agoThis note from the US National Fire Data Center: http://www.usfa.fema.gov/downloads/pdf/tfrs/v11i4.pdf suggests that a few hundred people die every year in the US because of fires started by people smoking in bed.
- dllthomas 13y agoI kind of think we separately need some better mechanism for dealing with addiction, abuse, and self-destruction, regardless of the context. Unfortunately, I don't yet have anything specific to propose.
- diydsp 13y agoI agree. I don't have a specific plan, either, but I have intuitions. The key things we need to address are people's natural spiritual and medical curiosity. In another thread, someone pointed out some hackers hack to scratch an itch, not just for fun. I believe the same can be said for needlepoint, carpentry and heroin. We could make space in society for people to explore the parallel worlds. Maybe a week per year research period. Many users I know of all types of drugs take them just to tolerate their jobs. We could somehow make work more tolerable. We could make everyday life more fulfilling and have less stigma attached to exploring alternate states of mind. We need to find a way to fit or shoehorn this stuff into our lives because we can't eradicate it. Perhaps this is the skill of the shamanic ritual and modern day music festivals... to put boundaries of time and space around the exploration of this alternate states of mind. We need to protect and shepherd people into safe places while they're experimenting and keep them away from responsible areas like driving and machinery while they're temporarily intoxicated. We need to keep them productive even if they're using.
- shabble 13y agoOne of the major downsides to most of the diverted licit opioids is that they're intended primarily for oral use, and hence contain all sorts of things that will do terrible things when injected directly into a vein. Tiny particles of tablet filler & binding usually wash up and get stuck in the lungs, leading to a pneumonia-like condition called Talcosis. Then you have the new "anti-abuse" formulations, which contain specific ingredients designed to be uncrushable, unpleasant if injected, or insoluble/gel-forming to prevent IV use. Given junkie creativity (and suppressed self-preservation instinct), there are various methods of bypassing these obstacles, but in doing so could affect the potency of the extracted remains by a factor of 2-10x. So now you have no idea how much you're dosing, as well as what's still along for the ride. At least heroin dealers would typically only cut with toxic adulterants by negligence, rather than intent. [not an opiate (ab)user, known a few]
- at-fates-hands 13y agoYou have to consider what the Mexican drug cartels would do if you regulated these drugs and essentially put them out of business. How do you think they would react??
- Nursie 13y agoWho gives a crap? All of a sudden they won't have hundreds of millions of people clamouring to give them money all the time.
- Bootvis 13y agoI'm not sure. What we do know is that their most profitable enterprise ceases to exist. Less profit means less money to spend on weapons, bribes and hiring goons. Sounds good to me!
- angersock 13y agoIn this corner, Los Zetas and the rest of the cartels. In that corner, Pfizer, Merck, Bayer, Dow. Somehow, my money's on Big Pharma. Especially if they get to spend money on security contractors. The basic reasoning here is that once you flood the markets with cheap, awesome, solid product the operating funds of the cartels go away. Destroy the market and you can't afford to be evil.
- ams6110 13y agoWhat did the criminal underground alcohol producers do when prohibition ended?
- samatman 13y agoCreate Las Vegas.
- MichaelGG 13y agoI'd suspect if you gave a 15-year exclusive license to a few companies, Mexico'd get cleaned up really fast. Dealing with the DEA and what not is one thing; but dealing with Monsanto?
- bayesianhorse 13y agoBanning isn't enough. These new drugs have to be detected somewhow, probably with mass-spectrometry, leading to all sorts of problems with detection, specificity, selectivity and the legal problem of how someone is supposed to know some incense contains these drugs...
- Nursie 13y ago>> Designer drugs are also likely to kill a whole lot of people, bolstering politicians who want to keep the status quo. Anything can bolster these schmucks. More deaths? We need to fight this scourge. Less deaths? Policy is working. Also at the moment the main causes of drug deaths in the UK are - > Drinking alcohol > Smoking tobacco > Heroin related (could be largely mitigated) > Mislabelled substances (PMA sold as MDMA, could be completely mitigated)
- roc 13y ago> "the main causes of drug deaths in the UK are" Does the UK not have the prescription drug abuse we see in the US?
- Nursie 13y agoI don't think we're anywhere near the level you guys are on that front, no. Or if we are it's still in the submarine phase and is a huge story waiting to be broken. Codeine is available over the counter from a pharmacist with no prescription (in limited, usually adulterated quantities), people who need more painkilling tend to get prescribed higher doses of codeine, or if it's more extreme they get morphine but are highly supervised and expected to account for their usage. I don't think we've ever been as easy about prescribing oxycodone et al. as I get the impression has happened in the US. --edit-- I am well prepared to be shown to be wrong about this, but nothing I've read has indicated it's such an issue here. --edit 2-- Also they seem to like to prescribe NSAIDS here, which (AFAICT) don't have much abuse potential.
- roc 13y ago> "as I get the impression has happened in the US." Yeah, you don't need to worry about the qualifiers. http://billingsgazette.com/news/opinion/editorial/gazette-opinion/gazette-opinion-too-many-pills-montana-must-stop-painkiller-abuse/article_8722c090-173b-597a-aeb4-ef113573af92.html http://billingsgazette.com/news/opinion/editorial/gazette-op... Maybe it's just that level of background exposure that set my expectations, but I'm (pleasantly) surprised that the problem might not be universal.