3 ms·
An email list, and a hierarchy of committers through whom changes bubble up will help a lot more than any number of project managers - list(s) can set prioritie
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
An email list, and a hierarchy of committers through whom changes bubble up will help a lot more than any number of project managers - list(s) can set priorities, explain rationales and keep everyone informed. And committer hierarchies work really well for splitting teams up along code lines
Yes ex-developers promoted into positions in that committeer
Hierarchy will do less development and more "steering". But they know that - as do editors at newspapers. Junio Hamano even writes interesting notes on it. But again only a fool hires an illiterate for that position. And only a fool creates a seperate parallel organisation to keep an eye on / communicate with, the software teams. Once upon a time there were few developers and software was a strategic project to reduce costs. Now it is everywhere - like literacy, it infects everything with outsized leverage.
And you cannot maintain two parallel organisations - one that does the business and one that then goes off and imements it. It's insanity.
Again I like to use the newspaper analogy - it makes it clear where we need to go. It is probably true that project managers are needed for an organisation that is illiterate at the board level, in the sales force and in the marketing dept.
But companies like GitHub are not showing us how to overlay old illiterate management styles on company with mostly developers - They are showing how to run a company when everyone in it can read and write.
Honestly I do not know how companies prior to printing press organised themselves - but I bet it was different after literacy was widespread - and I bet the old companies did not survive the new
- fbuilesv 13y agoIt's interesting that you mention Mr. Hamano since I was thinking about how Git or Linux works while writing my comment. I think we both agree that having someone who steers the ship is then fine, call it PM, higher-ups in the commit hierarchy, etc. The Linux kernel has people like like GregKH or even Linus who I'd call PMs, their main jobs are communication and reviews, not writing code. You don't need a parallel organization for this but you need to create some structure to support a big number of people working in different projects under the same umbrella. I think your comments are targeted more towards having someone "illiterate" steering the ship and that is a whole different thing that's not mentioned anywhere in the article. I won't argue anything in this regard since I think it's really dependent on the person and not the abstract role, but it seems (judging from the other comments in the thread) that most people have been burned by people with no knowledge giving direct orders on how to proceed.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoso we have highly skilled technical practitioners, intimately familiar with the codebase, such as that found in the "commit hierarchy" of Linux/git. i cannot equate them with PRoject/product/programme managers, especially not with the overriding focus on planned dates. We have a industrial management system based on the physical needs of large scale factory style production. And it is ignoring the management styles of the creAtive industries - where there is always a commit hierarchy and this not in it are ignored or supply finan e
- fbuilesv 13y agoI like your last paragraph. I don't know what the future will bring but I totally agree that today's world works mostly under an old school, factory-style management regime, which is not efficient in industries like ours. Having said that, I personally still see value in some of those old practices. As [lukatmyshu] mentioned in this thread: Think of [PMs] as oil in an engine. The best ones know how to communicate extremely well, are paragons of organization, and know how to facilitate decision making. Instead of getting in the way they make life easier for everybody. I do understand that's not the typical experience for most people in our line of work.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoAt the risk of dragging on a thread, I would suggest that a job function that requires "the best" before it adds significant value, and otherwise is anecdotally a -1 sounds like a job function it's risky to hire for.