4 ms·
"90% of the time when you go to the doctor, you just need the sanity check and the antibiotics." Sure, but what about the remaining 10%? Even "proper" doctors
by Tichy 18y ago
"90% of the time when you go to the doctor, you just need the sanity check and the antibiotics."
Sure, but what about the remaining 10%? Even "proper" doctors often mess up the diagnosis - would the nurses do so much better?
Actually I wonder about the antibiotics, too. Wouldn't the need for antibiotics already signify a serious condition? I know there is the tendency to just prescribe them for everything (even virus diseases), but maybe that is just bad doctors? I don't think it makes sense to say "we don't need more doctors, because doctors are bad anyway", so I think we would still be stuck with "we need more good doctors".
- tptacek 18y agoThey don't have to do much better; they escalate to doctors. Nobody's arguing that NP's should be performing appendectomies.
- Tichy 18y agoI understand that idea, I am just worried about the cases where the nurses fail to recognize a serious condition. Of course that could happen to a doctor, too, but overall, I imagine it to be a very upsetting situation if you really feel like you want to see a doctor, but your way is blocked by a nurse. What does the market say anyway? Do people want cheap nurses as an alternative to doctors? If so, I guess it would be fine, just let people choose where they want to go. But that is not necessarily what is happening. For example in Germany (very different system probably), the insurance company makes the rules about the kind of treatments they allow you.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoAll you need to do is give the nurses broad escalation criteria. Anything that doesn't perfectly fit the symptoms of the easy diseases gets escalated. Incidentally the few states where they are legal, the nurse clinics do very well.