5 ms·
This very long article is at once both thought-provoking and rather confused, like reading the beginning of a hundred interesting conversations, each interrupti
by javajosh 13y ago
This very long article is at once both thought-provoking and rather confused, like reading the beginning of a hundred interesting conversations, each interrupting the last before they get anywhere. I'm not really sure what to take away from it, other than "if you want to finish the conversation, buy the books."
The title here gives a clue as to what someone else got out of it. "Against Cynicism: A philosopher's brilliant reasons for living." We might infer that this was about reasons for living, that they are brilliant, and that cynicism isn't part of those reasons. And yet, I'm not entirely sure that "reasons for living" are what Sloterdijk is even addressing. It seems more like he's addressing the concern of minimizing suffering in a culture that's largely given up God. He's an atheist who admits that religion in general and the belief in God in particular has utility, and he's exploring replacement therapies. An eminently reasonable thing to do. But this isn't a reason for living: for the vast majority of people, the "reason for living" is simply that the alternative, death, is petrifying.
- VLM 13y ago"for the vast majority of people, the "reason for living" is simply that the alternative, death, is petrifying." Perhaps I'm unusually happy, but my reason is to have the most fun, which pretty strongly implies helping those around me have fun, while being focused on long term. Some sociocultural rules from the other side of the planet three thousand years ago are interesting and all that, but don't float my boat or fit my needs.
- javajosh 13y agoLet's say rather that the least common denominator reason for living is that, well, death sucks. Yes, of course are positive reasons to live, and while those are nice to have, they aren't as universal a motivator, I think, as simple fear of death.
- SCAQTony 13y agoI have to agree. Shakespeare: "For in that sleep of death what dreams may come...?" Or as brilliantly stated by XKCD, you end up going back into the "Lego box" http://xkcd.com/659/ http://xkcd.com/659/ To define what sucks about death is the concept of complete non-existence and the the total erasure of everything you ever were and consequently destined to never exist again. Your atoms may change into different forms but you will never experience it. That to me makes even the worst of life experiences better than death sentence known as "...we owe god one death."
- daviator88 13y agoShakespeare has a wonderfully ability to make me feel okay with my own mortality.
- regal 13y agoErnest Becker's 1974 Pulitzer Prize winner would agree with you [1]; in fact, the theory goes so far as to state that all of human culture is designed around avoidance of death, and even avoidance of the acceptance of the reality of true, complete death. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Denial_of_Death http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Denial_of_Death
- dsego 13y agoThanks for summarising it, I really didn't have the energy to go through the whole thing (been reading other stuff all day).