4 ms·
> Remind me where in the Constitution it says ... There's a lot that the Amendments, including the First, don't say. They are not literal descriptions of what
by a3n 13y ago
> Remind me where in the Constitution it says ...
There's a lot that the Amendments, including the First, don't say. They are not literal descriptions of what specifically is and what specifically is not allowed. They set the tone for the kind of things that should and should not be allowed.
When you judge a practice, or a law, against the First Amendment, you don't look for that specific practice in the text, you judge how much that practice supports or opposes the amendment.
The amendment does specifically mention the press, in a general way. The press does need information to function, and discouraging access to that information would tend to weaken the amendment. Which is why we're seeing credible discussion today that the NSA's dragnet metadata collection violates not only the Fourth Amendment, but the First, because the collected metadata is data mined for associations, which could tend to discourage and punish (room for discussion) "the right of the people peaceably to assemble."