2 ms·
In Australia at least, yes. Many have been found in contempt of court and jailed because of it. Does the right to not self incriminating extend to incriminating
by girvo 13y ago
In Australia at least, yes. Many have been found in contempt of court and jailed because of it. Does the right to not self incriminating extend to incriminating your source?
- lukifer 13y agoYou cannot be compelled to testify against yourself (or your spouse, law client, etc), but you can be compelled to testify against someone else, which is how subpoenas work.
- vacri 13y agoAustralia doesn't have a '5th' to take in the first place. It can be used against the common citizen that they refused to talk to police or to testify in certain circumstances. It's not going to prove that you're guilty, but it is allowed to add context. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_silence#Australia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_silence#Australia This being said, since the internet came of age, Australian journalists have hardly been behaving in a way that would suggest they deserve increased protections...
- girvo 13y agoI know, which is one of the many reasons I (ineffectually, before I found out I was going to cause nothing to change at that point) argued for a Bill of Rights when I was involved in youth politics. I was just giving another perspective :) my final question was aimed at a US audience, I was truly curious how it worked there RE. Not incriminating other people A journalist here just went to jail for not revealing her source to the court because one of our mining moguls dragged her into a trust case due to reporting on info regarding to it. Pretty horrid in my opinion. We have no truly defined rights here in Australia. That's what my law degree basically taught me. (that is exaggerating a little :P)
- sigzero 13y agoIt does not extend to your source. You invoke the 5th only for yourself.