3 ms·
Jesus christ. I argued for a Bill of Rights while participating in Youth Parliament here in Australia, and used USAs typically strong defence of freedoms as my
by girvo 13y ago
Jesus christ. I argued for a Bill of Rights while participating in Youth Parliament here in Australia, and used USAs typically strong defence of freedoms as my evidence.
And now all of that has been systematically ignored and weakened over the past few years (of course, it could have always been like this and I just hadn't noticed). It's a dammed shame, and I am no longer excited about possibly moving to Silicon Valley: I don't think I'll move at all anymore.
- ars 13y agoThere never was this sort of freedom for journalists. The fact that you think so is just a testament to how easily journalists can spread their messages. They always wanted there to be such a law, but there isn't and never was. I am not saying it might not be a good thing for this to be the law, I'm just saying it never existed.
- sigzero 13y agoYou are right, it never did. Yet almost every movie involving scenarios of lawyers and sources has it. As does any TV show and book. It is deeply ingrained in our thought process yet it is wrong (from the point of view their is no such protection). It is kind of amazing when you think about it.
- alanctgardner2 13y agoYou're confusing two different things: lawyers enjoy client-attorney privilege at every level in the US. For this to apply you must be a practicing attorney. Journalists don't enjoy similar protections because they aren't a self-regulating profession (there is no law appointing an entity to regulate journalists, as there is one to create the bar organizations).
- jasonlotito 13y agoWell, that's not entirely accurate. Many states have shield laws. They just don't apply at the federal level.
- girvo 13y agoOh, of course. I feel that there should be, however :)