3 ms·
I used to believe and repeat this rhetoric 10 years ago. But then I went into finance and started noticing that BLS data resembles a work of fiction at least as
by beagle3 13y ago
I used to believe and repeat this rhetoric 10 years ago. But then I went into finance and started noticing that BLS data resembles a work of fiction at least as much as it models reality; That CPI has been redefined through the years, and is basically not reproducibly measurable (hedonic adjustment and owner equivalent rent are both measured in a non-verifiable non reproducible way) and numbers are constantly revised in the least favorable direction when markets aren't looking (that is, numbers look better than they are when originally published, and then revised after most have already stopped looking at them)
And this got me wondering - did crime rate indeed go down? Or is it just that numbers are measured differently and thus look better?
- moocowduckquack 13y agoStuff like a tenfold drop in stolen cars in new york is hard to explain away with changes in recording.
- beagle3 13y agoWhile I generally agree, the devil is always in the details, and having no specific knowledge I do not reject the reported drop in crime, but I certainly do not accept it as gospel. Tangentially related anecdote: 15 years ago, a friend of mine bought a house on the (wrong side of an) edge of a crime reporting district in Philadelphia for $80k. Across the road (which wasn't a highway or anything, just another inner neighborhood road), an exact copy of the same house (same developer, same year, same project, same layout, same everything) went for $200k at the time. Three years later, the crime reporting districts changed, and his house (and a few others) were reported in te better district. His house value changed, practically overnight, from $100k to $240k. Ergo, report methodology can effectively affect related value significantly. Quantum measurement effects on a macroeconomic scale.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoIf it was one set of figures from one country then you might have a point, but you are effectively describing noise and for such a wide range of crimes across such a wide range of countries you would expect the noise from reporting changes between different jurisdictions to more or less cancel out.
- beagle3 13y agoI am not arguing or contradicting you in any way, as I do not have any specific knowledge - but there are globally misreported (or misunderstood, I won't argue semantics) cost-of-living figures, without requiring conspirators or any centralized planning - do not rule out global bias in reporting just because a mechanism for such bias is not evident.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI don't rule out bias, I am just noting that in this case it would seem unlikely to all be pushing in one direction for the reasons I stated.
- Zigurd 13y agoYou are right that one aspect of lower crime rates is that police department leadership, in some places, discourage reporting crimes. Especially if they have an incentive structure based on crime rates. There is enough variability in reporting rates to hide a lot of crime. BUT this article was very unsatisfying. The above factor is just one of many. And the problem is that paramilitary "boys' toys" enthusiasts, prison guard unions, recipients of anti-terrorism grants, and all the other interest groups are all contending to lead the low-crime parade. It's pretty certain that some crime is becoming less prevalent. It's hard to hide a shooting or stabbing victim. But these gains have to be defended against the kinds of fudging you describe. And, to reap the social and budget benefits of real reductions, we also have to call BS on false claims of the lock-'em-up interest groups. It could be that the answer is that more people know what a normal middle class life is like and therefore more people want to live that way, even if it is just aspirational.