5 ms·
I don't live there, so maybe I'm missing something, but is Silicon Valley really something to glamorize and try to replicate? I always thought that technology i
by vinceguidry 13y ago
I don't live there, so maybe I'm missing something, but is Silicon Valley really something to glamorize and try to replicate? I always thought that technology is supposed to be distributed rather than centralized. Centralizing something allows you to exploit economies of scale, but also invites parasites in to free-ride. And the Valley does seem to attract a lot of parasites.
- liquimoon 13y agoI think technology should be distributed to leverage the economy of scale. But here, I am talking about the startup ecosystem. If you look at the big Internet companies, you will be amazed to see how many of them come out of the valley. That's why the rest of the world is trying to jumpstart this. The problem is it's not as simple as copying what's working at the surface.
- robotcookies 13y agoTechnology (the product) can be decentralized. But the generation of ideas that create the products is a separate thing from the product itself. Many would say there is a geographic aspect to the generation of ideas... that people, for some reason, need to be in proximity to each other. When bright people work together they produce much more interesting things than when working in isolation from each other. And from observation, it also seems that bright people seek each other out. This isn't to say SV is great or doesn't have its issues, but it seems to attract the brightest people from around the world (and possibly 'parasites' as you mention, as well). I don't think most places like Canada want to replicate SV... just the part about creating large successful tech companies. The article suggests this might be helped by allowing people to actually get and stay there. It's not really about 'centralized technology' but more about creating a culture where people from around the world can come together and make these things happen.
- jister 13y ago>> I don't live there, so maybe I'm missing something, but is Silicon Valley really something to glamorize and try to replicate? Nope not really but you're in HN and most people here tend to think that Silicon Valley is like Mt. Olympus or something. There are a lot of startups out there that are very successful and not in Silicon Valley.
- liquimoon 13y agoBut the concentration is what counts here. After all, Silicon Valley is merely a region. You cannot compare it to the rest of the world.
- michaelochurch 13y agois Silicon Valley really something to glamorize and try to replicate? Silicon Valley has the lowest latency in searches, both for job seekers and for employers. If you're looking for someone with deep experience in 3 disjointed areas of technology, you can find that person in SV. You can't easily find that person anywhere else. You have to train someone into the role, or convince the one matching person in the world to move. For extremely specialized queries, SV still has a continuous labor market while the rest of the world is discrete. If you're doing the kind of get-big-or-die red-ocean gambit that VCs like to fund, that latency risk is undesirable. Other than that, I think SV is overrated. There are probably 20 places in the country (many cheaper and with fewer douches) where it's not hard to find generally smart, technical people in large numbers. Anyway, I can't imagine anyone under 45 willingly living in "Silicon Valley" unless that includes San Francisco. The reason for moving out to the suburbs is to get a cheaper place and more land, but the Valley doesn't have that going for it because even suburban houses with disastrous commutes are expensive.
- rdouble 13y agoAnyway, I can't imagine anyone under 45 willingly living in "Silicon Valley" In my experience, a large percentage of engineers of any age have suburban tendencies. There are way more "nerd's nerds" down in the valley. If you want to run into people who build robots as hobby projects, they will be at Menlo Park Techshop on the weekends, not at Dear Mom. (although I've heard these days that a lot of maker-hacker types live in Oakland)
- _delirium 13y agothey will be at Menlo Park Techshop on the weekends, not at Dear Mom SF isn't only bars; they could also be at Noisebridge.
- rdouble 13y agoIt would be cool if the Silicon Valley area could somehow be replicated without the tech industry. I wouldn't mind living in the Atherton of the 1950s.