3 ms·
"We don't know what the alternative might have been" I can make a guess: if Microsoft had refused to give people want they wanted, somebody else would have. Af
by Someone 13y ago
"We don't know what the alternative might have been"
I can make a guess: if Microsoft had refused to give people want they wanted, somebody else would have. After all, Windows more or less started out as a "copy the Macintosh, but keep backwards compatibility" exercise. IBM could build that, too (and did, with OS/2, which was even more closed than Windows) and chances were that Digital Research [edit: make that Novell; they bought DR in 1991] could have, too. What could Microsoft have done about that? Stubbornly selling something that users do not want would, IMO, just have led to a different winner.
I also fail to see why you would ever expect the average computer user today to be as knowledgeable of computers as that of 20 years ago. The demographics of 'computer user' have changed enormously over that time period.
Similar things have happened everywhere. We have people washing clothes who could not build a washing machine, people doing a bank teller's job with the help of an ATM who know nothing of double entry bookkeeping, people driving cars who don't even know what engine knocking is, people heating their home who don't even know how to make a fire _with_ a match, etc.
And yes, I think people who don't really know how their system boots or how a file system works miss out on a lot, but then, I don't really understand the underlying physics either.
- zanny 13y agoI'm not arguing consumer computing is bad. I think it is great, and you are right, it is inevitable. I'm more talking about how Windows of the 95 - 2008 period didn't ship with development tools (which were also behind non-student paywalls), terrible sysadmin tools, and nothing pointing a user of any Windows computer towards hacking on it. It was presented as a washing machine (mainly MS-office or MS-IE box) when it can do a lot more than wash clothes (general purpose software). There is a generation where a lot of potential techies were lost to their day to day compute platforms not having easily accessable or discoverable development platforms the way a c64 or Mac2 would have had (included, by necessity). I started on dos, which was one of the major learning points for me - as soon as Windows adopted a gui, you never experience the actual terminal of a computer anymore. Great for the consumer of a tool, terrible for a generation of unknowing would be hackers lost to a black box technology.