4 ms·
How exactly did the courts get into the business of censoring websites, anyway? Is it not isoHunt's first amendment right to tell people where to get pirated m
by jrockway 13y ago
How exactly did the courts get into the business of censoring websites, anyway? Is it not isoHunt's first amendment right to tell people where to get pirated movies from?
Follow-up question: how come the Usenet providers are not caught in this dragnet?
- hnha 13y agono one is using Usenet so please don't talk about it... ahem!
- throwawaykf02 13y agoWhere does speech end and "aiding and abetting" begin? Another way to think about it this: you have some property that has now become a haven of illegal activity (through no participation of your own) that is disrupting the local community. IANAL, but in such a case I'm guessing you could be compelled by the law to clean your property up. Even if the law has no way to compel, shouldn't there be?
- MWil 13y agothat's why there are minimum legal requirements. they are minimal. you are not required to police your own website, even if it's full of illegal activity. the only way you would be responsible for doing so is if you a) affirmatively invited the activity or b) get notice from companies through a proper takedown notice and they specifically let you know what is illegal and where (url).
- benologist 13y agoCourts got into the business of censoring websites when they found websites got into the big business of infringing other's rights. Usenet is not immune: http://torrentfreak.com/newzbin2-the-mpaas-usenet-enemy-1-calls-it-quits-121129/ http://torrentfreak.com/newzbin2-the-mpaas-usenet-enemy-1-ca...
- jrockway 13y agoTo me, the problem is that torrents are descriptions of how to get the content, not the content. It's like banning a chemistry textbook because you could learn how to make a bomb.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 13y agothe problem is that torrents are descriptions of how to get the content, not the content For all practical purposes, they have become the same thing. Courts are not obliged to accept carefully worded definitions when the technology involved is a mere instrumentality. Also, even if we do accept the description argument, you still have to consider that it's a description of how to obtain someone else's property. The first amendment doesn't give you the right to market detailed instructions on how to rob individual branches of a bank, for example, which is loosely analogous to IP infringement (insofar as physical currency is only a representation of a currency abstraction, this is actually a good parallel).
- jrockway 13y agoThe first amendment doesn't give you the right to market detailed instructions on how to rob individual branches of a bank, for example Citation needed.
- chipotle_coyote 13y agohttp://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/95-815.pdf http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/95-815.pdf Relevantly, the section reading: The Supreme Court held that "advocacy of the use of force or of law violation" is protected unless "such advocacy is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action." This was specifically referring to the case the famous line about "shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic" not being protected speech; it would certainly seem to me that attempting to "market detailed instructions on how to rob individual branches of a bank" would match the exception above. You can publish material telling someone how to make an explosive device, but material telling readers precisely where best to put that explosive device to crack open the safe at the Bank of America office on Fifth Street? Probably not going to survive a legal challenge.
- awda 13y agoThe MPAA approaches usenet providers about this quietly in the last year or so. Usenet providers have since voluntarily implemented automatic takedown systems, and the MPAA or other rightsholders have implemented automated takedown submission systems. As a result, binary usenet is more or less devoid of easily searchable content nowadays. It was only a matter of time.
- wmf 13y agoCopyright is recognized as an explicit exception to free speech, but the boundary is not clear. Links to infringing content live in that gray area. One of the earliest DMCA cases, ALS v. Remarq, involved Usenet. Usenet has the same "whack-a-mole" problem as P2P and cyberlockers where deleting infringing content often results in a different user re-uploading the same content (perhaps with a minimally different file name) within hours. IMO this kind of situation is handled very poorly by the DMCA, but I don't have any specific suggestion about how to fix it.