4 ms·
Right, there is a syntax. No punctuation, is what I should say. Again, the DSL I gave is not optimal. It would take a few iterations. My argument is that the
by breck 13y ago
Right, there is a syntax. No punctuation, is what I should say.
Again, the DSL I gave is not optimal. It would take a few iterations.
My argument is that the few idiosyncrasies of zone file syntax are not trivial. Road signs are trivial. Hundreds of millions of people can see a sign and get it right away. My argument is that DNS could be trivial, and my prediction is a Space based DSL will emerge that makes it so.
- eropple 13y ago...But why do I care? Like, why would I use this? Yes, it takes an hour or so to understand simple DNS and it can certainly take weeks or even years to really understand complex DNS...but it's not the zone file format that makes this hard, it's that DNS is hard. "More efficient" doesn't make me care because it's already efficient enough that the bottleneck in DNS is elsewhere. Being more useful, doing things I can't already do, makes me care. So why should I care?
- breck 13y agoDNS creates an alias from a name to the implementation. This is really powerful for a set of reasons. One, humans think with a combinatorially larger language than numbers, so having to work with addresses like 723.123.322.123 would be painfully slow. "Apple.com" is much easier. Two, you can refactor the implementation without changing the interface. Ie, you can build a whole new Apple server, but just change the alias, and not have to teach the whole world to now go to Apple2.com. It's pretty neat. The whole thing should be pretty simple. However, it's not. If it were simple, you would see a lot of programmers interacting with DNS on a more meaningful level (than just buying domains and changing A records and CNAME records according to steps they Googled and not according to an understanding of how DNS works). Each DNS record could just be an object encoded in Space. Doing so would allow you to start innovating at a core part of the Internet, instead of on a tower of cryptic stacks. IE: record domain apple.com ip4 723.123.322.123 ip6 21:21:213:213:::213 expires 2/23/2013 createdBy Tim Cook mirrors 1 723.123.322.322 2 123.123.322.322
- eropple 13y agoSetting your condescension aside, I am a programmer, and I do interact with DNS on a more meaningful level. It's not the interface: it's the concepts that are hard.