3 ms·
Eh, I think Gladwell has a point here. "Captain, Guam condition is no good." doesn't count as "speaking up" when a situation is potentially life-threatening. Th
by bjourne 13y ago
Eh, I think Gladwell has a point here. "Captain, Guam condition is no good." doesn't count as "speaking up" when a situation is potentially life-threatening. Then you say something like "This approach is very dangerous, I think we should try something else."
- SilasX 13y agoThe set of practices known as Crew (or Cockpit) Resource management formalize this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crew_resource_management#Communication http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crew_resource_management#Commun... So in this case, the proper action would be: 1) Get attention: "Captain ..." 2) State concern: "I'm concerned that a visual approach is too risky in this weather." 3) State the problem: "Visual approaches only work in low wind (or whatever conditions), and the weather report says we're not within those conditions." 4) State a solution: "I suggest we change plans and prepare for [alternate landing method], starting with [first step]." 5) Get buy-in: "Do you agree with that course of action, Captain?" (Note that the pilot did just the first two ... or maybe only half of the second or third.)