3 ms·
An ERISA like system would just put major impetus for the movement from defined benefit to defined contribution for state and local governments. Which trend ha
by btilly 13y ago
An ERISA like system would just put major impetus for the movement from defined benefit to defined contribution for state and local governments. Which trend has already happened in the private sector.
I'm sure a lot of people are wondering WTF I'm talking about, and why it matters.
A defined benefit pension says, "You will get this much per year when you retire." A defined contribution plan says, "We will put this much into your retirement fund."
The problem with a defined benefit plan is that to do it properly, you need to set aside money today for that purpose. And then you need to invest it. However the most effective long-term investments are risky asset classes like stocks. But the downside of those is that there will be years where your pension fund loses money..a lot of money. If you are under pressure to guarantee that your plan is fully funded at all times, in those years you'll have an insanely huge obligation.
How big a deal is this? Consider well that governments around the country all have large pension plans that they have decreed should make about 6.5%. Which, of course, can't be done with safe asset classes. So they are pushed into risky asset classes, but not just any risky one, risky ones with a track record of stable returns. Like private equity. When private equity went belly up in the 1980s it caused the S&L crisis. If it happens again, the numbers now are 10x as large, and it is largely government pension funds that wind up underfunded to the tune of something like a trillion dollars.
By contrast a defined contribution plan just requires that you pay a defined amount into an investment plan, which is then free to be invested in the most sensible asset classes.