4 ms·
Detroit Bankruptcy: What Congress must do to prevent future disasters
- rayiner 13y agoWhat Congress needs to do is get out of retirement entirely (including 401k's, etc) except to maintain and protect Social Security as the last-ditch retirement system.
- bilbo0s 13y ago"...except to maintain and protect Social Security as the last-ditch retirement system..." I suspect that's the rub. I don't have ALL of the information on Social Security, but the system is probably a good deal more difficult to fix than it seems. From both a fiscal and political perspective.
- rayiner 13y agoSocial Security's unfunded liability over the infinite future horizon is equal to 4% of future taxable payroll, or 1.4% of future GDP: http://cnsnews.com/news/article/social-security-faces-96t-unfunded-liabilities-83894-household http://cnsnews.com/news/article/social-security-faces-96t-un.... A 4% increase in FICA taxes would be hard to swallow for many families, but let's face it, it's not going to make or break anyone and it would permanently fix Social Security.
- btilly 13y agoAlternately Social Security is projected to be solvent for decades if the US federal government simply pays back the treasury bonds which are invested in Social Security. I know, actually paying bonds that are owed to Social Security is a radical notion. As would be raising taxes for that purpose.
- ams6110 13y agoI'd go farther and say they need to get out of Social Security too. Have an option to grandfather in those who are too close to retirement to do anything different... give everyone else a payout that rolls into a personal investment account.
- rayiner 13y agoThat's politically untenable. Every time there was the failure of a pension fund or a stock market crash, there would be calls to bail out retirees. The government can't not be involved in providing a safety net retirement system. The alternative to Social Security is funneling even more money into Wall Street in the form of personal investment accounts, and that would be more capital sloshing around looking for the next bubble. The fact is that people trust Social Security's "pay it forward" system a lot more than they trust Wall Street.
- btilly 13y agoI strongly suggest that you look at what happened in Australia when a similar system was implemented. http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-05-30/in-australia-retirement-saving-done-right http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-05-30/in-australia...
- ams6110 13y agoGovernment funding a safety net retirement program has quite a short history. I don't think we've come anywhere close to establishing that it's a must-have.
- rayiner 13y ago> Government funding a safety net retirement program has quite a short history. Relative to what? The government has funded retirement for about 1/3 the length of the republic, and for the majority of the modern industrial era. Moreover, such programs have been widespread in every country that has achieved modern levels of industrialization. If we use infant morality rate as a proxy measure of civilization, then in the last year before Social Security was implemented, 1934, the U.S. was roughly as developed as Pakistan or Rwanda is today (~60 per 1000 live births).
- ams6110 13y agoCongress should extend ERISA or a similar set of rules to municipal and state governments. This would force governments to manage their pension systems in a safe way But then the politicians couldn't use the pension programs as personal slush funds. Won't happen.
- btilly 13y agoAn ERISA like system would just put major impetus for the movement from defined benefit to defined contribution for state and local governments. Which trend has already happened in the private sector. I'm sure a lot of people are wondering WTF I'm talking about, and why it matters. A defined benefit pension says, "You will get this much per year when you retire." A defined contribution plan says, "We will put this much into your retirement fund." The problem with a defined benefit plan is that to do it properly, you need to set aside money today for that purpose. And then you need to invest it. However the most effective long-term investments are risky asset classes like stocks. But the downside of those is that there will be years where your pension fund loses money..a lot of money. If you are under pressure to guarantee that your plan is fully funded at all times, in those years you'll have an insanely huge obligation. How big a deal is this? Consider well that governments around the country all have large pension plans that they have decreed should make about 6.5%. Which, of course, can't be done with safe asset classes. So they are pushed into risky asset classes, but not just any risky one, risky ones with a track record of stable returns. Like private equity. When private equity went belly up in the 1980s it caused the S&L crisis. If it happens again, the numbers now are 10x as large, and it is largely government pension funds that wind up underfunded to the tune of something like a trillion dollars. By contrast a defined contribution plan just requires that you pay a defined amount into an investment plan, which is then free to be invested in the most sensible asset classes.