2 ms·
> the Supreme Court decided in the government's favor If you close your eyes really hard, you can convince yourself that the Supreme Court isn't part of govern
by baddox 13y ago
> the Supreme Court decided in the government's favor
If you close your eyes really hard, you can convince yourself that the Supreme Court isn't part of government and that therefore this phrase isn't completely ludicrous.
- pyre 13y agoWhich is a better rephrasing: * The judicial branch decided in the executive branch's favour. * America decided in America's favour. If you abstract far enough out, we're all part of the same group (humans), so any thing done that favours anyone else is just us being self-interested, right?
- dragonwriter 13y ago> If you close your eyes really hard, you can convince yourself that the Supreme Court isn't part of government and that therefore this phrase isn't completely ludicrous. Its not ludicrous as it is; the executive branch represents the government, as such, in court. The courts may be part of the same government, but they can, and do, rule against the government position in cases in which the government is a party, as well as ruling for the government in some such cases, making it perfectly reasonable to describe the Supreme Court deciding for (or against, as applicable) the government.
- betterunix 13y agoHow is that phrase ludicrous if we acknowledge that the courts are a part of the government? Our government is deliberately partitioned into branches that may or may not work together. The Supreme Court can and does rule against the government that it is a part of; the Justices are not servants of the Attorney General nor of the President.