3 ms·
The government's legal position is that indiscriminately dumping large datasets of metadata into a database is not a search. But later looking things up in tha
by btilly 13y ago
The government's legal position is that indiscriminately dumping large datasets of metadata into a database is not a search. But later looking things up in that database is, and has to be supported by further warrants.
Thus under the theory the government follows, the activity that you can prove happened is not a search. So you have no standing to sue. And if they look you up later (of course filing appropriate warrants with the FISA court), then you can't prove it happened, so you still can't sue.
- joyeuse6701 13y agoI'm surprised no one has put the feet to the fire of those that argue this and ask them if it's ok for police to : 'walk into your house, take pictures of all your possessions and copy all your documents at any given time' and say it's not a warrant because they aren't going to sift through it later. It's unfortunate that there is such a disconnect between real and virtual policies. People who can't handle the abstraction shouldn't be making decisions regarding it.
- jacques_chester 13y agoThis is an interesting line of argument that I hope someone puts before the court. Previously, search in a legal sense combined two elements that we've always blurred together: 1. Collection of data 2. Intepretation of the data. So when a human searches, they are comingled. Light enters the eye, is processed into images in the brain, is elevated into consciousness and draws connections in the front cortex and elsewhere. But an automated system can do it in two stages. The pictures could be recorded and never analysed. The question is whether the act of searching includes both data gathering and analysis as inseparable parts or whether they are seperable. And if they are seperable, where does the search reside: in the data, or the analysis? Reversing your analogy, the NSA approach is like the police having housefly-sized drones in every house, keeping HD video of everything that goes on. Most of the time, nobody sees it. The data is gathered but not analysed. Is that search?
- daegloe 13y agoI've always been under the impression that the legal definition of search and seizure requires "examination."
- btilly 13y agoThat is clearly not OK because the 4th specifically mentions that your house is protected. The issue here is indiscriminate copying of data from third parties through whom your information traveled. Under the government theory it is not a search (because nobody has looked at it), it is not a seizure (because you still have your data), and your person, house, papers and effects were not touched. Therefore it is an activity that lies outside the protection of the Constitutional phrase, The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated...
- specialist 13y agoFirst graf is an excellent summary. Ran into the same logic fighting to protect the secret ballot. Many jurisdictions tie ballots to voters thru unique barcodes. Excellent for ballot tracking, accountability. Terrible for voter privacy. Government argued that although data is collected, it's never looked at, so no violation of privacy. Ditto prescanning ballots before election day. It's not "tabulation" until they run the final report. All the draft reports beforehand don't count. These Kipling "just so stories" logic makes me nuts.
- ozi 13y ago>The government's legal position is that indiscriminately dumping large datasets of metadata into a database is not a search. Okay, then let's start by challenging this legal position. Just because they interpret something a certain way doesn't mean we have to accept it.
- btilly 13y agoThis position is being challenged in court by multiple lawsuits. I bring up the government's theory not because I agree with it, but because it is virtually impossible to understand their public statements without understanding their reasoning.
- GoodIntentions 13y agoBy the same logic, I suppose you could walk into a bank vault, take all the money home, but not really consider it theft until you spend it. Complete BS.