10 ms·
It should be noted that their position on standing comes straight from Clapper v. Amnesty International, No. 11-1025 which the Supreme Court decided in the gove
by btilly 13y ago
It should be noted that their position on standing comes straight from Clapper v. Amnesty International, No. 11-1025 which the Supreme Court decided in the government's favor this year.
The decision is that likely targets of surveillance who cannot prove that they were ACTUALLY surveilled have no standing to file a court case where they could issue subpoenas to the government which could prove whether they were. In short it is a catch-22. You can't sue about being unconstitutionally searched unless you can prove it happened. But you can't prove it happened without suing.
And the Supreme Court thinks that this is acceptable.
- lonnyk 13y agoIs it more accurate to say that the Supreme Court interpreted the law and the law makes this acceptable?
- btilly 13y agoBy my non-lawyerly understanding, no. The question of when standing to sue exists is a question of common law, not statutory law. Had they decided that standing exists, then they would have had opportunity to rule on the law itself.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> The question of when standing to sue exists is a question of common law, not statutory law. Standing has both Constitutional elements and prudential elements (the latter could be referred to as "common law"); the actual injury element is Constitutional, but the prohibition on generalized rather than particular injury is prudential. Here, a particularized injury is raised but the problem is that the injury is speculative rather than actual, so the problem would be with Constitutional requirements for standing, not the prudential elements.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoAll those wars, all for naught. "Battle not with monsters lest ye become a monster; and if you gaze into the abyss the abyss gazes into you." - Nietzsche
- greenyoda 13y ago"You can't sue about being unconstitutionally searched unless you can prove it happened." I thought the current lawsuits claim to prove this by asserting that: - The NSA got access to all of Verizon's customer metadata (as indicated by a leaked FISA Court decision). - The plaintiffs are customers of Verizon. - Therefore the plaintiffs' metadata was provided to the NSA.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- btilly 13y agoThe government's legal position is that indiscriminately dumping large datasets of metadata into a database is not a search. But later looking things up in that database is, and has to be supported by further warrants. Thus under the theory the government follows, the activity that you can prove happened is not a search. So you have no standing to sue. And if they look you up later (of course filing appropriate warrants with the FISA court), then you can't prove it happened, so you still can't sue.
- joyeuse6701 13y agoI'm surprised no one has put the feet to the fire of those that argue this and ask them if it's ok for police to : 'walk into your house, take pictures of all your possessions and copy all your documents at any given time' and say it's not a warrant because they aren't going to sift through it later. It's unfortunate that there is such a disconnect between real and virtual policies. People who can't handle the abstraction shouldn't be making decisions regarding it.
- jacques_chester 13y agoThis is an interesting line of argument that I hope someone puts before the court. Previously, search in a legal sense combined two elements that we've always blurred together: 1. Collection of data 2. Intepretation of the data. So when a human searches, they are comingled. Light enters the eye, is processed into images in the brain, is elevated into consciousness and draws connections in the front cortex and elsewhere. But an automated system can do it in two stages. The pictures could be recorded and never analysed. The question is whether the act of searching includes both data gathering and analysis as inseparable parts or whether they are seperable. And if they are seperable, where does the search reside: in the data, or the analysis? Reversing your analogy, the NSA approach is like the police having housefly-sized drones in every house, keeping HD video of everything that goes on. Most of the time, nobody sees it. The data is gathered but not analysed. Is that search?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- cavilling_elite 13y agoSo one could send out a bunch of dummy encryption files, get caught, get in jail, then show that the files were empty, then sue? Sounds easy, just hope one doesn't land in gitmo!
- RexRollman 13y agoKafka would be proud.
- rhizome 13y agoOh, it's worse than that. You don't have standing even if you know you were surveilled: https://www.eff.org/cases/al-haramain https://www.eff.org/cases/al-haramain As long as all possible proof is classified, nobody will ever have standing, and as we've seen in the Snowden case, classified info does not lose its classification when it's released to the public.
- zwegner 13y agoI had heard of that case before, but didn't know why it was dismissed: "The case was subsequently dismissed by the 9th Circuit on the grounds of sovereign immunity." And sure enough: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity "In the United States, the federal government has sovereign immunity and may not be sued unless it has waived its immunity or consented to suit." So apparently the government cannot break the law, by definition. What the hell?!
- rgbrenner 13y ago"So apparently the government cannot break the law, by definition. What the hell?!" history/explanation in the 'introductory' section: http://www.law.harvard.edu/faculty/hjackson/FedSovereign_21.pdf http://www.law.harvard.edu/faculty/hjackson/FedSovereign_21....
- jervisfm 13y agoIANAL but if the government is right by definition (on a legal basis), does that mean that the various suits now being filed don't have any teeth ?
- abecedarius 13y agoThat history is pretty unsatisfying when it first quotes Holmes, presumably a century or so after the constitution was ratified. So next I looked at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_United_States#Federal_sovereign_immunity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_Unite... and it cites a case from 1983. This makes me at least wonder at the idea it derives directly from English law at the founding of the U.S.; "you can't sue the King" does not obviously transfer right over in the atmosphere of the time. ianal or historian.
- baddox 13y ago> the Supreme Court decided in the government's favor If you close your eyes really hard, you can convince yourself that the Supreme Court isn't part of government and that therefore this phrase isn't completely ludicrous.
- pyre 13y agoWhich is a better rephrasing: * The judicial branch decided in the executive branch's favour. * America decided in America's favour. If you abstract far enough out, we're all part of the same group (humans), so any thing done that favours anyone else is just us being self-interested, right?
- dragonwriter 13y ago> If you close your eyes really hard, you can convince yourself that the Supreme Court isn't part of government and that therefore this phrase isn't completely ludicrous. Its not ludicrous as it is; the executive branch represents the government, as such, in court. The courts may be part of the same government, but they can, and do, rule against the government position in cases in which the government is a party, as well as ruling for the government in some such cases, making it perfectly reasonable to describe the Supreme Court deciding for (or against, as applicable) the government.
- betterunix 13y agoHow is that phrase ludicrous if we acknowledge that the courts are a part of the government? Our government is deliberately partitioned into branches that may or may not work together. The Supreme Court can and does rule against the government that it is a part of; the Justices are not servants of the Attorney General nor of the President.
- rayiner 13y ago> And the Supreme Court thinks that this is acceptable. Courts hate to decide issues if they can avoid deciding issues, and conservative courts especially so. Conservatives would prefer political issues (more surveillance versus less surveillance) to play out in the political sphere, not in the courts. It goes back to the idea that the un-elected judiciary is supposed to be the weakest branch of government, and therefore should defer to the elected branches if it is possible to do so.
- pitiburi 13y agoI know about that idea of deferring decision from un-elected to elected authorities. But, the problem is nobody elects NSA hierarchies. Or FBI, CIA, etc. And they have such amount of power that THEY decide over elected officials, and not the other way around. No president can take a decision against what the powers inside the NSA want. The officials nominated by the president to head those agencies are either guys imposed to them from within that agency, or a nominal authority with no real saying in the power structure inside. The more you think about it, the more you realize is a catch-22.
- tptacek 13y agoWhen you elect a president, you're also electing the leaders of the DoJ, DoD and NSA. This is such a fundamental concept in our system of government that the Constitution spells out a check and balance system for principal officers of the USG.
- adestefan 13y agoNote that all of those positions are also approved by the legislative branch through Senate confirmations. The only unique position is the Director of the FBI which holds a 10 year appointment.
- n09n 13y agoWhy do you conclude that they find it acceptable? Shouldn't judges be ruling on the merits of the case, not based on what outcome they find pleasing?
- charonn0 13y agoThey should indeed. Courts of law should rule on what the law says; the court of public opinion is the proper venue for determining what what the law ought to say.
- igravious 13y agoNo, the court of sound reason is.
- btilly 13y agoWhy do you conclude that they find it acceptable? The majority made their ruling despite lawyers for the other side pointing out this catch-22, and the minority decision outlining this exact scenario as a reason to have granted standing. I do not think that the majority could have so ruled if they found the existence of this catch-22 to be unacceptable.
- lukev 13y agoI don't think it's acceptable either, but really it's an impossible question from either direction. Consider the alternative ruling; all covert surveillance at all including (including legitimate, warranted intelligence collection) would become impossible. Classification itself would only be a matter of nobody bothering to ask. Of course, such total transparency is a viable philosophical viewpoint, but unfortunately it's not really on the table in any of the current discussions.
- betterunix 13y ago"Of course, such total transparency is a viable philosophical viewpoint, but unfortunately it's not really on the table in any of the current discussions." That speaks more to the current political environment than to the validity of transparency or secrecy. We should be very concerned that we have gotten to the point where surveillance and intelligence collection are considered to be more important than the ability of the people to hold the government accountable for its actions via the court system.
- igravious 13y agoQuestion. At what mythical point in time could the people reasonably hold their government accountable for its actions via the court system? I perhaps never got this particular prelapsarian memo as I may have been indisposed at the time.
- quantumpotato_ 13y agoYes. HN, please keep the discussion going strong. So glad to see the NSA's surveillance hasn't died off the front page.
- res0nat0r 13y agoThis argument keeps coming up on HN lately. Either the HN echo chamber is in full effect, or just the age of people posting not aware of history...but secrecy has been alive and well and around long before 80% of the people on this website were born. Recent reference: The Cold War. I'm sure older references can be brought up if needed. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_War http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_War http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_War_(TV_series) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_War_(TV_series)
- perlpimp 13y agoThey can do extraordinary renditions and indefinite detention without trial. I say take the axes and budozers and excavators to buildings of NSA and deliver citizen's disconnection service.
- mtgx 13y agoI don't think this will work again. This time even the administration admitted they are spying on people. And last time the Supreme Court decision was 5-4.
- Andrew_Quentin 13y agoSurely the fact that Verizon was ordered to hand over all its phone records for a period of three months means that anyone who is a Verizon customer has standing.