4 ms·
Only S/MIME, PGP or similarly encrypted mail messages are secure. All other mail is routed through various servers which may or may not use an encrypted connect
by peterwwillis 13y ago
Only S/MIME, PGP or similarly encrypted mail messages are secure. All other mail is routed through various servers which may or may not use an encrypted connection. It's like trusting the post office to never read your mail (which they have the authority to do if they perceive some kind of safety threat). Encrypt the message contents if you care for message privacy.
If you want sender/receiver privacy too, you can try using Tor hidden services direct to the individual. I can't think of any other way off the top of my head to send SMTP mail and completely conceal the recipient(s).
- contingencies 13y agoencrypted mail messages are secure What is secure? If government sezies your key, in some jurisdictions they can compel you to release your passphrase (if one is required), then they can go back and decrypt absolutely everything you ever sent. (OTR gets around this but this is largely by leaving the network layer location privacy / initial authentication / key exchange problems out of scope.) Finally, traffic analysis is pretty powerful. Even if Eve can't read your messages, she can see who they went to and when (and maybe who they in turn communicated with afterwards) and thus easily determine probable relationships - Tor based endpoint, or not. (Hrrm ... but two Tor based endpoints, on the other hand...)
- eikenberry 13y agoNothing is secure if you discount the rule of law. http://xkcd.com/538/ http://xkcd.com/538/
- contingencies 13y agoI don't think we were discounting the rule of law. We were going with the 'currently some western governments will force you to reveal your password' legal reality.
- peterwwillis 13y agoTor attempts to work around traffic analysis by using fixed-length records, and being a bridge helps hide your traffic with other people's. But nothing's perfect. "Secure" in this context means "not readable by anyone but the recipient". Of course, if you have the recipient in custody, this is the easiest method to decrypt the messages: http://xkcd.com/538/ http://xkcd.com/538/ (OTR-style cryptography is nice, but sucks for store-and-forward communication; for a comporably difficult message to decrypt more than once, use one-time pads - but don't complain to be about distributing the pad dictionary, that's totally out of scope here ;)
- mikevm 13y agoSo why not use Gmail with PGP?
- riquito 13y agoIt's certainly an option, but you must use a client like Thunderbird to do it, loosing the ubiquity of the web interface. Maybe when window.crypto will be standardized and with a good browser extension we will have security and easy of use.
- mehrzad 13y ago>good browser extension http://www.mailvelope.com/ http://www.mailvelope.com/ https://github.com/crised/SafeGmail https://github.com/crised/SafeGmail No good (edit: stable and drop-in) Firefox tool yet.
- peterwwillis 13y agoOr just attach pgp files to your e-mail and use it with any e-mail client or server.