4 ms·
SurfaceRT is a $900-million mistake right now. There are so many ways to make SurfaceRT a compelling product. If it supported Win32 API, IF it had domain-joini
by dragontamer 13y ago
SurfaceRT is a $900-million mistake right now.
There are so many ways to make SurfaceRT a compelling product. If it supported Win32 API, IF it had domain-joining support, if it wasn't completely locked down to the Windows Store... maybe it'd be a compelling buy. But as it is, it has all of the disadvantages of tablets (locked down, proprietary API), with few of the advantages of Windows.
Then you've got XBox One mistake. So much wasted potential there...
Windows 8 has to happen though, the computing industry is evolving towards touch controls, and as primitive as Windows8 is with touch... its a step in the right direction for Microsoft. But they need to be more sensitive to their business partners.
- blacktulip 13y agoRT is a joke but what's wrong with XBox One?
- dragontamer 13y agoCompared to the PS4, the XBox One hardware has 30% less shaders on the GPU, is using DDR3 RAM instead of faster GDDR5 RAM, and is using the same CPU as the PS4. All the while, it costs $100 more than the PS4. So for the first time in XBox's history, the XBox is launching with strictly weaker hardware than its closest competitor. (XBox 360 at least had a GPU that was 2x stronger than the PS3 GPU, and the XBox 360 also had faster RAM. PS3 won on CPU power... but lost out on everything else.) There is terrible, terrible press across the whole internet about the XBox One-Eighty. Video Gamers overall have a negative impression on it. http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2013/06/12 http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2013/06/12 http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2013/06/21 http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2013/06/21
- yulaow 13y agoand not only this. The worst part is the total failure of the presentation of the console. I know they now have deleted the big part of the main restrictions, but still they undermined the trust of the buyers.It is not a little problem
- freehunter 13y ago>XBox 360 at least had a GPU that was 2x stronger than the PS3 GPU [et al] And did it matter at all? From what I remember of this current generation's history, if games looked any different on the PS3 than the 360, the developers blamed it on the tools and how difficult the PS3 was to program for, not on the weaker hardware. Developers made cross-platform titles for the Xbox first and ported to the PS3 because Xbox was easier. When I was 16 years old I argued console hardware specs. These days I don't hear many experience gamers mention it at all, because when it comes down to it, minor differences in specs doesn't really matter.
- dragontamer 13y agoWhy was the PS3 harder to program for? Because its GPU was out of date, its RAM was split, and its architecture sucked. Programming the PS3 "incorrectly" leads to extremely poor performance. Certain memory transfers on the PS3 are just straight up broken: http://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/1007286/ps3-hardware-slow-broken http://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/1007286/ps3-hardwar... The XBox was "easier" to program for because it was a more balanced system. Overall, the XBox360 was both simpler and more powerful. By making XBox360 more powerful, previous soft-exclusives like Final Fantasy and Metal Gear Solid made their way to the XBox360. Sony lost a lot of publishers because of the boneheaded hardware they shoved into developer's faces. It is Microsoft that has made this mistake in this generation. Not only from a policy stand point against indie gamers (ie: Oddworld moving to PS4 exclusive title. As well as SuperGiant Games making Transistor PS4 exclusive), but also by launching with weaker (yet paradoxically more expensive) hardware. The PS4 will be easier to program for, it has a simpler more unified architecture, and Sony's policies are more friendly towards developers. While it barely matters for the end consumer, it is easy to see which systems producers will prefer in the coming generation.
- angersock 13y ago"The PS4 will be easier to program for, it has a simpler more unified architecture, and Sony's policies are more friendly towards developers." The architectures seem near identical--the only big difference would seem to be that the XBO will have dedicated framebuffer memory, probably hidden behind a system call anyways. As for being more friendly to developers, Microsoft has always had the best tools and documentation for developers (long live SGI, poor bastards). I don't really see where you're getting this from.
- commandar 13y ago>XBox 360 at least had a GPU that was 2x stronger than the PS3 GPU Eh? Where are you getting that? The Xbox 360 Xenos GPU was based on ATI's R520 and the PS3's RSX was based on Nvidia's G70 architecture. They were roughly equivalent to each company's flagship Radeon X1800 and GeForce 7800 lines at the time. The real design win for the 360 was a shared memory pool instead of a split CPU/GPU memory architecture, but I've never seen anything to suggest that the 360 had a GPU anywhere near "2x stronger."
- dragontamer 13y agoXBox360 crushes PS3 in virtually every microbenchmark: http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20071217224458AAC2wb9 http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20071217224458AA... 2x faster Triangle Setup rate, 4x faster Vertex Shader processing, 50% faster pixel shaders, 2x faster Anti-Aliasing... The PS3 makes up for it as they use all of those Cell processors basically as a GPU. But in terms of pure GPU Girth, the XBox360 was just straight up easier to use and more powerful. -------------- Basically... despite all the major press about the PS3 "supercomputer", XBox360 was a simpler, better designed gaming machine. In in this upcomming generation, PS4 out-xboxed the XBoxOne. The PS4 is a dead-simple straightforward architecture that simply throws more hardware at the problem. (while somehow being cheaper...)
- commandar 13y agoA lot of that is a demonstration in why microbenchmarks are usually worthless for determining real world performance. Xenos has a unified shader architecture while RSX does not. That means that during microbenchmarks, it can dedicate all of its shaders to that task, and put up relatively impressive numbers. In reality, that means that those shaders can't be used for anything else, meaning your real world performance will look nothing like the microbenchmark. AA performance is almost entirely due to the on-package EDRAM. While that was a smart design decision, it's not indicative of some huge overall power advantage. Look, Microsoft made a number of very smart design choices with the 360 that have allowed developers to squeeze a lot out of the hardware, there's no doubting that. I think it's also fair to say that Xenos is a bit faster than the RSX -- as was the case with that generation of discrete GPUs from ATI and Nvidia -- but throwing around things like twice as powerful and "crushes" is getting into hyperbole territory if you're looking at actual performance from the hardware.
- samsnelling 13y agoOP might not think there is something wrong with the XBox One... however I there is no denying that it was a PR catastrophe with the it's always online stuff. Flip flopping after a product introduction does not bode well IMO. Edit: OP does not like the XBox One ... my bad. :)
- y0ghur7_xxx 13y agohttp://venturebeat.com/2013/07/13/microsofts-xbox-one-chief-product-officer-admits-big-mistakes-in-messaging/ http://venturebeat.com/2013/07/13/microsofts-xbox-one-chief-... http://www.neoseeker.com/news/23234-microsofts-one-mistake-pressing-reset-on-the-xbox-ones-aspirations-of-a-digital-future/ http://www.neoseeker.com/news/23234-microsofts-one-mistake-p...
- dragontamer 13y agoAnd of course... http://www.idigitaltimes.com/articles/18620/20130701/xbox-180-don-mattrick-fired-steve-ballmer.htm http://www.idigitaltimes.com/articles/18620/20130701/xbox-18... Don Mattrick is now fired.
- guizzy 13y agoNothing per se at this point, but their previous stance on DRM allowed their main competitor to gain a large PR advantage. However saying that the Xbox One will fail like the WinRT did is very premature; the PS3 had a slow start and still made a respectable showing this generation, and the 3DS was considered a debacle until a price cut and the right games came along and it suddenly exploded in popularity.
- jdjb 13y agoI feel we'll see the same thing with the Wii U. Everyone is dismissing it right now and for good reason (lack of games). But Nintendo did announce at least 1 game for every major line they have running at the last E3 so I expect the Wii U sales will start to jump up right around we see the PS4 and XB1 releases.
- guizzy 13y agoI hope so; I bought one a couple of weeks ago. Nintendo seems to be getting ready for a major push, but I think it will need to make a price cut; not because the console is a bad deal, but because they need to generate positive headlines in the gaming press for the gaming community to stop seeing it as having no future.
- dragontamer 13y agoWiiU is the only backwards compatible system, showing strong support for consumer rights. I frankly am most excited about WiiU this generation, but I'm holding off on buying one till more games come out. But Earthbound on Virtual Console, and Pikmin 3 coming out make it a compelling buy already IMO.
- schabernakk 13y agoI think he is referring to the PR disaster the Xbox One had a couple weeks back with the only online requirement, Kinect always listening and other lockdown mechanisms implemented on the machines making sharing games or similar things more or less impossible. I don't know it this will have much impact on the actual sale numbers, the release date is still quite some time in the future and the PS4 despite all the love it currently gets from the gaming scene also requires a Sony account you have to pay monthly to be usable. I am pretty sure it will play out like it always does: lots of complaining and in the end it will get bought nevertheless. [1] [1] http://img5.imageshack.us/img5/6062/1258035395841.jpg http://img5.imageshack.us/img5/6062/1258035395841.jpg
- speeder 13y agoWhen Xbox One was announced, if I facepalmed harder my head would detach from my neck. Then Sony and made their announcements, of features that are actually normal and expected since consoles exist, as if it was something totally new and awesome, in a very obvious way to give more ammo to Microsoft keep shooting themselves. It was very entertaining. Specially looking at the stock market (when Xbone wss announced, SONY shares jumped 8%) too.
- jaredmcateer 13y agoThere was a very good comment I read about this that basically said, it's very telling of how bad the industry is screwing over their consumers when the most exciting thing you hear this year is that Sony just isn't going to mess with the status quo.
- CamperBob2 13y agoExactly. To make Sony look consumer-friendly, you have to get up pretty early in the morning and make big mistakes before breakfast.
- yulaow 13y agoI'm of the idea that microsoft auto-killed the surface rt in the exact moment in which they decided to release it at the same time of the surface pro. Maybe, if they had let pass something like 1 year or 18 months between the two (without annuncing at all the surface pro in this time), more people would have tried the rt and it would have gained some momentum in the market.
- bcoates 13y agoThe RT had months to sink or swim on its own and was already something nobody wanted by the time you could order a Pro. The market confusion between the two is enormous, and it's not going in the direction Microsoft wanted: I routinely run into people who are under the impression that all tablets with Windows that they see are crippled ARM devices and not usable computers. If tablets running Windows are Microsoft's future they badly poisoned the well with RT.
- vondur 13y agoThe surface RT was targeted at Consumers, I don't think the lack of joining active directory would be something most people would miss. I don't think most people would care about the Windows store lock down, provided that the store has good apps in it. They were trying to use the fact that it has a Real copy of Office on it as a selling feature, except that Office on the RT's ran really poorly.
- alipang 13y agoThere's lots of business people (a subset of consumers) who'd might consider buying a surface for their home if they could use it effectively for their work as a bonus. Unfortunately, no active directory support and terrible performance in Office means its not really compelling. Just saying, not all consumers are "my mom" who just wants to play candy crush saga and check their email.
- zmmmmm 13y ago> The surface RT was targeted at Consumers There's the problem - it's not actually targeted at anybody properly. It's a business tablet (office pre-installed, heavily marketed with its keyboard and flip stand, all the ads show chic business people in suits dancing around). But it can't join a domain, won't run the line-of-business apps people actually need, doesn't support VBA (so your excel sheet will load but if it is at all interesting, it won't work), and the built-in office is not actually licensed for commercial use, so businesses who care about the fine details of that sort of thing can't actually use it anyway. Ok, so its a consumer tablet. But it's not got essential things like a good gmail app (didn't even have outlook when it shipped), youtube appp, it sucks for viewing photos you plug in on a USB drive, can't run Chrome, has (or had) few games worth running and has a confusing new UI that is hard to figure out, so playing with it in the store usually results in frustration. It's half awesome for each of its audiences, but its got showstoppers for both of them. It's a true first generation product, and if there was time and room for the second generation it could be awesome. But Haswell is here and the OEMs have no patience for waiting around for RT to improve when they can be selling something that actually meets everyone's needs.
- doctorpangloss 13y ago>IF it had domain-joining support Perhaps Microsoft's problem is that features like "domain-joining support" make their products "compelling."
- lmm 13y agoKeeping your files and settings synced between multiple machines is a huge problem, and frankly MS has the best implementation available today. Who cares if they haven't given it a sexy name?
- cschmidt 13y agoThe problem is that "domain-joining support" means nothing to me (and probably 99.9% of the world). It may be a really cool syncing solution, but I'd never get that out of the name.
- outside1234 13y agoI know its hard to believe, but most folks work at large enterprises.
- phaemon 13y agoI know it's hard to believe, but they really don't.
- stdgy 13y agoHere are some numbers, in case either of you would prefer to use evidence to back up your statements. http://www.census.gov/econ/smallbus.html http://www.census.gov/econ/smallbus.html
- outside1234 13y agothanks - i thought this was well known but i guess not. :)
- JonFish85 13y agoI feel like their biggest problem was confusion. Apple does this very well: their products aren't terribly confusing. As a consumer thinking about buying a tablet computer, you think OK there's the iPad, but what else? Oh, Microsoft has a tablet. Hey, it runs Windows, I know windows! But Windows RT? It doesn't run my existing card games? I thought it was Windows? Oh but if I buy the pro, it'll run my Windows stuff? How do I install my card games? But it's more money? What's different about that one? Screw it, I'll just get the iPad.
- junto 13y agoThis hits the nail on the head. It isn't just that Apple do this well, very well, but Microsoft are just terrible at it!
- LordHumungous 13y agoAlso, it was marketed as something that's a laptop replacement- it runs windows! it has a keyboard! Oh but it only has 15GB of available storage. Never mind, I guess I'll just get a laptop after all.
- dombili 13y agoSpot on. It's really strange that enormous companies like Microsoft can't see why consumers choose Apple. Maybe they do see it, but can't execute their plan, but I doubt that's the case with Microsoft. What would stop them? They have the money, marketing, talented people in place. There's no excuse.
- tmzt 13y agoWhich is pretty sad given the answer is so simple: 1. Small number of products and product lines make it easier to explain where each one fits in your "digital lifestyle." 2. Mostly numerical differences within those product lines, amount of storage and overall computing power. Memory for desktops and laptops. Retina is an obvious exception to this, but most likely transitional. 3. Mostly self descriptive naming, no Sony style model numbers, no overly cute but inconsistant naming. (Apple reserves this for features, mostly ones that only developers ever see.) 4. Visible price points, value emphasised over price. (Same reason I don't expect a plastic iPhone outside of possibly China.) Price points match up with point #1, more storage costs more in mostly even increments.
- smacktoward 13y agoThe problem is that if you add all those compelling features to Surface RT, you end up with Surface Pro. Which brings you right back to the question of why Surface RT needs to exist. (The answer: because Surface Pro is too expensive to appeal to the consumer tablet market, and because Microsoft wants to hedge its bets in case Intel can't catch up to ARM in the mobile space. But both of those are reasons why Microsoft would want Surface RT to exist, not why a customer would.)
- dragontamer 13y agoNot really. Win32 API existed on MIPS machines back when Windows NT was ported over to MIPS. I'm not asking for x86 compatibility, I'm just asking for a way for Chrome / Firefox to be cross-compiled onto the SurfaceRT. Win32 API is the only real reason why people use Windows. Take that away, and you've got... well... SurfaceRT.
- davidgerard 13y agoYep. You literally need devs to be able to push a button in Visual Studio and their app is RT-ready. Or you don't have apps.
- peterkelly 13y agoWin32 should be in a nursing home right now awaiting death. They should have just made a clean break from it. I can't understand why anyone would want to deal with that abomination in this day and age. And given that it's ARM, you wouldn't be able to run any of your existing apps anyway, without the vendors recompiling (and quite possibly having to update their code in the process).
- com2kid 13y ago> Win32 should be in a nursing home right now awaiting death. It is well tested, has high performance due to its heritage, and is really damn flexible. You rarely find yourself going "well that isn't possible" with Win32 given how many iterations the API has been through. Unfortunately making a general purpose API of any sort tends to get ugly as more and more stuff is added to it, and then add in legacy requirements, and yes things are pretty icky at times. But any other API that is capable of as much as Win32 is would end up looking almost as bad, minus a lot of the legacy cruft, except of course in the time it takes to develop such an all encompassing API, you'd end up with legacy cruft all of your own!
- revscat 13y agoThe same could be said of Cocoa.
- dottrap 13y agoCocoa (like everything) has some rough patches, but overall is clean, elegant, and has a pretty consistent feel and vision. Proof is that ARC exists. This is the only reason compiler tools like ARC are possible. If Cocoa were too inconsistent, ARC could not be exist. Given that Cocoa's origins are from the 80's (NeXT) and Foundation is still with us today on iOS (and UIKit is very similar/familiar to AppKit), this is an extraordinary accomplishment and it has succeeded better and longer than any of its contemporaries.
- lloeki 13y ago