4 ms·
The problematic thing about Linus's behavior is not its direct effects but the example it sets. Even if one can justify his behavior in terms of his responsibi
by notacoward 13y ago
The problematic thing about Linus's behavior is not its direct effects but the example it sets. Even if one can justify his behavior in terms of his responsibilities at the top of the technical hierarchy, that doesn't justify worse behavior by those lower down. Others see what he does and take it one step further. Then, in the absence of a correction from him, they take it another step further, until they're just as nasty as their own pathologies allow them to be, and newcomers start to imitate that right off the bat. Just one "Al, that was over the line" comment from Linus would damp that feedback loop. The continued absence of leadership on that front ends up affecting the overall tone far more than the occasional one-on-one outburst.
P.S. To cheery, since you've been hellbanned: that's a false dichotomy. I'm not suggesting that people should be artificially nice. I'm not a nice guy myself. I'm just suggesting that discussions should be kept focused and fact-based, not made personal or nasty for the sake of entertainment or sheer bloody-mindedness. That's what I see both on LKML and here, and it serves no purpose. It's not honest, it's not efficient, it's just being a dick.
- cheery 13y agoSo is it problematic for you that others are themselves and behave like real people instead of behaving like corporate puppets or politicians? Based on my experience, you can keep your politeness to yourself. I've been doing stupid things a lot. I've heard both political "concerns" and "stop doing that faggot" sort of criticism. The latter has always actually worked. The former has made things worse, because I have not always understood polite talk which uses too many nouns. It has made people think I behave like an ass just to annoy them, whereas I actually always try to be nice to others. Politeness is censorship at worst -- you can still abuse people yet you can't clearly tell that something was harmful.