3 ms·
Ignoring the actual assessment of "Is Linus too abusive?"...do those who defend Linus think there's no middle ground between harsh and benevolent forms of dicta
by danso 13y ago
Ignoring the actual assessment of "Is Linus too abusive?"...do those who defend Linus think there's no middle ground between harsh and benevolent forms of dictatorship (let's also ignore evaluating the goodness of dictatorships in general)?
In other words, does harshness positively correlate with success? Sure, you can cite Steve Jobs. But others could cite Woz, who while delivered plenty of harsh technical criticisms of his own, still seems to have avoided doing it in a way that denigrated both the person and the work.
- hhw 13y agoThe middle ground is Linus continuing to be who he is, and the corporate types can be as professional as their employers require. I strongly disagree with Sharp's premise that the entire kernel team should act professionally just because there are corporations paying kernel developers, who should somehow have elevated status because they now account for 80% of the development. The corporations are the ones who chose to play in a volunteer sandbox, and they are in essence volunteers of the project themselves; it's just their employees who aren't. That relationship is between the paid developers and their employers, not between the paid developers and the project.
- sp332 13y agoIn part of the conversation Sharp spoke up in, Linus was instructing another maintainer, Greg, to learn how to yell at people because he is currently too much of a pushover. Sharp's point is that maintainers should not encourage each other to verbally abuse submitters. There's a difference between being nice and being a doormat, but Linus is acting like there isn't.