4 ms·
This sort of comment is exactly what is wrong what the world. What is your expertise in this area? Are you a anthropologist?? I suspect you are just one of th
by aaron695 13y ago
This sort of comment is exactly what is wrong what the world.
What is your expertise in this area? Are you a anthropologist??
I suspect you are just one of these sick people who like the idea mini zoos with humans in them.
These are human beings. They deserve access to modern medicines like the rest of us of the world even if you lose this precious zoo.
How are their women treated? That is the ones who don't die in child birth? Going off other primitive societies probably not great no matter what the Hollywood idea of how these societies operate and everything is great.
This sickness of how the majority of the population would never ever want to live like this if they had a choice but somehow the people living it are having the time of their lives is bizarre.
For all we know this island is just another North Korea and although I respect nations statehood I don't pretend it's somehow a moral decision not to get involved.
- rapind 13y agoYou do realize that there are massive amounts of people who are part of our world that are living in worse conditions than this tribe is? How about we focus on them first before we decide that our way of life is so superior just because a minority of us have regular access to modern medicine... I'm positive you don't need to be an anthropologist to realize this. I don't even understand the zoo reference. This is not a man made entrapment, it's their home. "Leave them alone" doesn't mean starting island tours. This world cop attitude is incredibly egotistic. It assumes that we've found the superior way of life. Evidence points to the contrary when you consider the number of species we've played a key role in extinguishing and endangering with our super amazing society.
- OvidNaso 13y ago>You do realize that there are massive amounts of people who are part of our world that are living in worse conditions than this tribe is? How about we focus on them first before we decide that our way of life is so superior just because a minority of us have regular access to modern medicine... Why should we focus on them? Your logic is that modern medicine is not an improvement or a factor in relieving suffering, but is only an illusion of our egotistical viewpoint. Why would it help those who are 'part of our world' that have insufficient access?
- ctdonath 13y agoFor all we know this island is just another North Korea For all we know this island is a tropical paradise. Reading further down the comments on the linked page (you did read the whole thing, right?) there's an additional encounter described which, shall we say, indicates they're quite content. I'm all for providing guidance and assistance to the poor, and intervening when serious moral problems are systemic (abuse, wanton violence, diseases untreated, etc.). I'm also all for leaving people alone when they make it very clear they've got things under control, are content with their situation, want you to leave them alone, and there is no indication of moral problems.
- edvinbesic 13y agoI think your comment is what's "wrong" with the world. You are applying your western values onto a completely foreign culture. Modern medicine? I'm sure after having survived for that long, they are perfectly capable of taking care of themselves. You want to give them jeans and t-shirts too? Maybe the gift of starbucks? It's the opposite of a zoo that the op is talking about.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bkmartin 13y agoWho cares if their civilization is 65,000 years old or 2,000 years old. They have clearly indicated, as a matter of their own free will, that they are not interested in our big ships, little ships, helicopters, cameras, or anything else they've seen of us. So why do WE have some moral authority or responsibility to show them "what they're missing". Your perspective is relative to your own life. In order to "inform" them of their options we'd have to basically invade their space, go against their free will, and would probably extinguish most of the population in the process. Once again, as the OP said... LEAVE THEM ALONE!
- moogleii 13y agoThey're part of the Andamanese people, of which there is data (from the surrounding islands described in the article you read). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andamanese http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andamanese Also, if it's no one's call to determine whether they leave or not, why would it be anyone's call to unilaterally interject into their society? Besides, I figure if some of those people do really want to leave, they can set up camp near the beach/wreck unarmed (probably at the risk of civil war, but hey, it's their call). One of us will probably notice eventually. And to build on that, if you really want to give them free choice, rather than going into their island to forcibly "enlighten" them, build them a removed, but easily reachable dock in the reef/wreck or something like that. From there you can do all sorts of things. A mini library, a vessel, etc. Though I wonder if any of them have even bothered to explore the extant wreck.
- BasDirks 13y agoYou just want them to be part of (y)our own zoo.
- gokhan 13y agoYou live in a dream world, my friend. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/what-happens-when-an-uncontacted-tribe-meets-civilisation-6358885.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/what-happen... http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2024011/Uncontacted-Amazon-tribe-missing-attack-armed-drug-traffickers.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2024011/Uncontacted-...
- martswite 13y agoIt's almost like you didn't read the words the parent wrote, he never advocated sailing on over and starting tours... These people want to be left alone and should be left alone. They've survived for 65000 years on a tiny island in the middle of the ocean. I'd say the rest of the "developed" world has something to learn from the way these people sustain themselves without, looking from the outside in, destroying a beautiful tropical island. For 65000 years
- mkessy 13y agoI would bet that any experts on this matter would advise the same thing: leave them alone. Why do you think there are strict laws banning travel to the island? The people themselves have made it very clear that they want to be left alone. Your mentality is the same one that missionaries and conquistadors use to justify imperialistic domination. If they want to be left alone what gives you the right to impose your way of life? And if you actually read the article and do some basic research you would notice that the entire reason the island didn't become a mini zoo is because the Sentinelese people themselves have resisted intervention and subsequently there are laws banning intervention. You have such a western centric world police attitude it is pretty gross and pompous. You're basically suggesting destroying a culture we know nothing about because of some false sense of moral obligation. Rash, illogical decision making is what is wrong with this world, and that is exactly what you're advocating.
- pandler 13y agoThat's a little presumptuous, don't you think? What gave you the impression that these people need to be saved, and from what? You're absolutely right. These are human beings. Treat them like human beings, not pitiful beings that you need to save because they don't have C-sections and cars and Xanax and lawyers. Stop acting like you know what is best for them. What is your expertise in this area? If you are concerned about their health, then it is best that we stay away anyway. History (and even this article) has taught us that isolated cultures are incredibly susceptible to our diseases (a.k.a. diseases they have never had contact with), and often times the results are fatal.
- celticninja 13y agothey have survived there for 65000 years, what are you going to bring themthat will ensure they are still there in another 65000 years? Nothing. You want to bring them medicine, but with that comes illnesses they have never been exposed to, you want to bring them food, excellent take along obesity with you. You want them to have access to modern amenities that they have never required but could become dependent on. Tell you what go drop a couple of crates of jack daniles and few 1000 packs of marlboro and some mcdonalds just so they know what they are missing out on. There is a vast difference between these people and their society and North Korea. In NK the ruling elite have access to everything youmention and the general population do not. On this island they all have equal access to the same stuff, sure some tribal leader may get the "big bit of chicken" or first choice when it comes to games night, but there is not the inequality that exists in NK.
- workbench 13y ago> How are their women treated? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaPYwlXOTzQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaPYwlXOTzQ Just fine it would seem
- pg 13y agoAnd this sort of comment is exactly what's wrong with HN. You could have made these same points more effectively without baiting the person you're replying to.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoAll you have to do is issue a decree that encourages people to upvote civility and downvote incivility, as opposed to the current standard which says upvote agreement and downvote disagreement. People upvoted this guy because they agreed with his fundamental points despite the baiting, and in turn he received positive feedback. I think maybe you underestimate the effect karma has on posting behavior; it's not just about pushing comments up and down the page.
- icelancer 13y ago>All you have to do is issue a decree that encourages people to upvote civility and downvote incivility, as opposed to the current standard which says upvote agreement and downvote disagreement. This doesn't matter. Doesn't work on reddit, doesn't work on StackOverflow, and won't work anywhere else.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoI'd be interested in reading more about that if you have a link. Reddit says to "moderate based on quality, not opinion" whereas PG said explicitly to do the opposite. (I can't remember how to find the link atm, but it was a comment in some thread on HN that I've seen people refer to.) http://www.reddit.com/wiki/reddiquette http://www.reddit.com/wiki/reddiquette I also found this discussion, which says that in practice there will always be a middle ground between moderating based on quality and moderating based on opinion: http://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/1g14yo/is_there_anybody_on_reddit_who_honestly_believes/ http://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/1g14yo/is_th... because our ego bias is to moderate based on opinion. However that's why a guideline to moderate based on quality pulls things towards the middle.
- itsybitsycoder 13y agoAre YOU an anthropologist? Because the men in many primitive societies had to be taught by the colonists to treat women as inferiors, and that's well-documented by anthropologists. It sounds like you have a single caricature of what "primitive societies" are like, and using that as a basis for a lot of assumptions about the Sentinelese.