3 ms·
Some remarks about the article: 1. you can't make information always for pay - why? - because it costs nothing to copy it and it's cheap to store terabytes of
by visarga 13y ago
Some remarks about the article:
1. you can't make information always for pay - why? - because it costs nothing to copy it and it's cheap to store terabytes of it
2. it is impossible to monitor all copying and make payments for everything - imagine how intrusive this kind of monitoring would be and how much overhead
3. the idea that everyone should have an unique online identity for tracking and payments is stupid - we'd lose all privacy, even as little as we have left; we don't want to be like China where you need to show your ID at the internet cafe
4. Yes, there is a problem with "power law distributions" of content like Google and App Store, but that needs to be changed by allowing customization, making of lists, and aggregation - I appreciate this insight
My rant on the subject:
I think he is fighting the future. Instead of total tracking and micropayments for everything, why don't we make a flat copyright tax and distribute it by popularity of content? It would be so much less overhead - we only need to track the number of views and divide.
Instead of trying to maintain monetization as it was in the past, into the future, why not embrace free culture and go ahead with basic human income? People create for love a creation too, not just for money. I'd say the best creations are works of love, not just works for money.
His power-law vs bell-curve insight is great but I think I got one that is even better (contains his insight and goes deeper still): we need to apply two criteria for improving society
1. differentiation - we need to maximize it by empowering creativity; why should we all see the same news? that would make for a monoculture. Instead, we should to pick and choose our feeds, each one of us differently. Similarly, we're better off with unique skills, unique perspectives on life and technology, and so on. We should encourage the variety.
2. integration - this is complementary to the 1st. The idea is that people need to be brought together to communicate, travel, make commerce and so on. As long as we are integrated, the system self regulates and can better cope with problems.
An anecdote: what is the difference between Facebook and Reddit? I'd say that the main difference is network topology; FB works by keeping you in your bubble of "friends" while reddit always exposes you to new people, on every page - that makes for better integration. The ability to subscribe/unsubscribe from subreddis improves personalization. Also, the comment history makes each user differentiated because the user will reply to different people. That's why we have such a higher level of creativity and participation in reddit compared to FB, that's why people get involved in deeper, more thoughtful discussions on reddit - it has more differentiation and integration.
Disclosure: I didn't invent this integration-differentiation idea. It comes from Giulio Tononi's Integrated Information Theory of Consciousness (I reused the concepts on society instead of the brain). This is a video presenting the theory: http://vimeo.com/53787308 http://vimeo.com/53787308
- lovemenot 13y ago>> 1. you can't make information always for pay - why? - because it costs nothing to copy it and it's cheap to store terabytes of it. If you changed the word information to data, I'd agree with you. We cannot hope to build an economy on top of charging money for the following: "I am going to the pub with Dave tonight". That data string, once released is never coming back. But, assuming we are not yet living in a panopticon, you don't know which pub nor which Dave. If you really want that information my authoritative interpretation will cost you. This seemingly minor nitpick helps us towards designing a solution to Jaron's problem.