9 ms·
San Jose State suspends online courses
- winstonian 13y ago> "We are experimenting and learning. That to me is a positive," Thrun said. Lulz.
- ramblerman 13y agowhat are you laughing at exactly?
- glesica 13y agoI personally found the quote to be in poor taste to a certain extent. He's talking about experimenting with people's lives. Yes, the students agreed, at least in some sense, to be a part of the experiment, but it is still a rather callous response in my mind.
- bayesianhorse 13y agoHe's trying to see a positive aspect. He isn't quoted with everything he said.
- cjfont 13y agoI basically came here to say this, as that comment stuck out from the article for me. I was thinking, that it must be nice to experiment using students' tuition money. I'm pretty sure the student didn't expect to be part of an experiment when they signed up.
- brianherbert 13y agoI know this is a different situation but... I completed half of an MBA program in the classroom (1+ yrs), then moved out of state and had to switch to an online program at another university, both of which were AACSB accredited. I must say, the online program was much more challenging, from almost all areas like personal responsibility, participation and academic rigor. The only area that could use improvement is testing, where some professors would prefer multiple choice questions, but this is a problem in any program. Regarding the San Jose classes, I think a lot of undergraduate courses essentially run on autopilot so if a student isn't interested, of course they aren't going to learn anything.
- michaelrbock 13y agoAs some who really enjoys online courses, this is really disappointing news. I know it takes a huge amount of dedication to finish an online class (especially a free one where the cost of dropping out is zero). Hopefully Udacity et al can figure out the pedagogy before the Georgia Tech online CS masters begins (http://www.omscs.gatech.edu http://www.omscs.gatech.edu).
- psbp 13y agoI bet there will be many similar cases before the behavior of students taking MOOCs changes. I just hope it doesn't dissuade the effort. I'm sure the long-term benefit of the effort is worth it.
- bayesianhorse 13y agoThe behavior of students won't change quickly, maybe not at all. The outside expectations might have to be lowered. Maybe a diagnostic exam should be offered.
- michaelrbock 13y agoFrom what I understand, the admission criteria for the GT OMS is that one is accepted conditionally until he/she passes 2 courses with a B or better, and then is fully admitted.
- volandovengo 13y agoI recently interviewed many students who were taking online classes as opposed to in person classes. I was surprised to learn that most chose to do them online so that they can cheat on the tests. Free from instructor supervision all tests were open book and thus were much easier than taking them in person. While many of us have high ideals for online education, I've learned that the majority of students get a degree for the diploma first and the education second.
- prostoalex 13y agoI don't think with SJSU set up there was ever an assumption that the tests were going to be online. What's surprising is that three months ago we've heard a completely different story: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/30/education/colleges-adapt-online-courses-to-ease-burden.html?partner=rss&emc=rss&_r=2&pagewanted=all& http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/30/education/colleges-adapt-o... "Usually, two of every five students earn a grade below C and must retake the course or change career plans. So last spring, Ellen Junn, the provost, visited Anant Agarwal, an M.I.T. professor who taught a free online version of the circuits class, to ask whether San Jose State could become a living lab for his course, the first offering from edX, an online collaboration of Harvard and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. ... The results were striking: 91 percent of those in the blended section passed, compared with 59 percent in the traditional class."
- jdc 13y agoThis seems like a simple matter of having all the tests written under invigilators.
- gadgetdevil 13y agoA bigger red flag would be if almost all of the students passed the final. I'm not an advocate for deliberately failing students: the exam should be designed so that an A shows true mastery and understanding.
- psbp 13y agoMany of my university's teachers took pride in their low pass rates. Not because they failed so many students, but because they passed a minority that had truly mastered the material.
- jarek 13y agoAnd some of my university teachers simply made the exams so difficult and long, the scores had little correlation with actual mastery of material (Jim Barby, I'm looking at your midterm).
- voyou 13y agoThe job of a university teacher is to help students learn - if a student fails the class, then the teacher has failed to do their job. Sure, it's possible that some of the blame for that failure may lie with the student, but nonetheless, the teacher still failed to achieve what they set out to do. A teacher failing a student is like a programmer shipping buggy software - it may be the case that, because of circumstances beyond your control (incomplete specs or dysfunctional management; unmotivated students or weak syllabuses), you couldn't do your best work in a particular instance, and you don't necessarily need to feel guilty about that; but you shouldn't be proud of it.
- Jach 13y agoThe problem with this point of view is that X classes are taken in parallel. So you start getting competition among the managers/teachers for your time, as each one understands that "spend all your time on just my class, my suggested resources, and as much time with just me as you need" will lead to the optimal amount of help they can give. They can't do any more as ultimately it's the student's job to learn and the transfer of tacit knowledge is incredibly difficult -- you can lead a horse to water etc. Some teachers give up on doing anything important around the crunch times, knowing they can't win (typically humanities teachers at a primarily technical or engineering or project-based school), some teachers just lessen the load as much as they're comfortable with, others take an "I'm the most important and difficult" attitude and the only one who will get an A will be the one who got an F in at least one other class. I wish schools would restructure to be serial with context-dependent branching, much like learning on the job tends to be, that way you can spend Y weeks focusing intently on a small spectrum of topics, then move on. Some classes are 3 hours every week for 12ish weeks, if you serialized that you could be done in 12 days. Plus the student and the professor would be in harmony, each having the other's undivided attention.
- rtcoms 13y agoAccording to me, examination system for online courses would be better like GRE system. Student should be allowed to take course from anywhere but he should go to the authorized center for exam.
- ritchiea 13y agoI'm distinctly of two minds about this. On one hand I believe interacting with other people is essential to learning. That studying together, or talking about a text, or hacking on a project together is where the best sort of critical thinking germinates. In that sense I am happy to see some evidence in favor of my hunch. On the other hand, the course material that online classes are making available for free is tremendously valuable. I've never finished an online course but I have begun to regularly use online course materials as a supplemental resource to books I'm reading and to projects I'm working on. I'm concerned that enthusiasm for publishing course materials online will dry up if evidence shows it's not a silver bullet for the world's higher education problems. In other words, I'm concerned that expectations are far too high and that educators and institutions are going to lose interest in a fantastic innovation just because it doesn't solve all our problems.
- bayesianhorse 13y agoOnline courses don't discourage collaborative learning. In some cases, they encourage it even. On the other hand, if all your peers in your offline world don't care for your courses at all, then solo studying is better than nothing...
- EzGraphs 13y agoOnline courses may not actively discourage collaboration, but they certainly do not force it in the same way that is possible in a traditional classroom. Don't get me wrong, I am a huge supporter of online courses. But a teacher staring you down, asking you a question, or encouraging you to work on a project in a small group is much more attention-grabbing than many online teaching mechanisms available.
- bayesianhorse 13y agoMost offline universitary education I have witnessed didn't work that way though.
- simonv3 13y agoFailure rates that high are normal at many European universities. The idea there often is "let many people in, but let them fail out if they don't make the cut". Not everyone is suited to some of the rigours of higher education, and when you make it freely available, more people are going to try it out, and more people are going to fail. I wouldn't call a 58% failure rate a bad thing.
- ics 13y agoMy understanding is that the failure they're referring to is among those paying the $150 to take the course for credit. I agree with your point (presumably many taking the course, free or otherwise, aren't college students) but this would be an important distinction.
- mustpax 13y agoFor the 44 to 24 percent of students who passed the course, this was not a failure at all. I don't see why they should be denied access to education because the likelihood of failing the course is higher. Online courses should be offered cheaper than regular on-site courses to take the increased risk into account, but that doesn't mean they should not be offered at all. Many price points, many products.
- glesica 13y agoBut if your customers don't understand the product then all bets are off and you have a moral (and, frankly, self-serving) responsibility to explain the product to them. The way it sounds to me, SJSU and Udacity and are going to take the time to study the data and figure out why it is that so many students failed. If, and this seems pretty likely to me, it turns out that the students were confused about the product (the courses) then I would imagine that steps will be taken to clarify things so that people can make choices that will lead to the best-possible outcomes. Many price points, many products doesn't work if people don't understand the products.
- trevelyan 13y agoIn the education market, customers do not know what they are purchasing by definition. This is why there is so much crap in the industry -- companies have an incentive to spend money on marketing rather than content. The latest round of MOOCs are not really monetizing educational content (which is and has been online elsewhere, often for free). They are packaging institutional prestige, the same dynamic Facebook used to drive student adoption. Khan Academy is the exception.
- bayesianhorse 13y agoA lot of the material on coursera isn't that easily available for free. The courses usually take a new and integrated aproach that you would see in a university course, created and presented by an expert instructor. I don't care for their prestige, but probably coursera is using the instutional prestige as a selection criterion, and it works, mostly. I also think Udacity is more in between Khan Academy and Coursera, in that Udacity tries to find new ways of online instruction.
- nazgulnarsil 13y agoThat's not much worse than the STEM failure rates of live attendance students. Source: I attend SJSU.
- codezero 13y agoFor introductory undergraduate courses?
- oblique63 13y agoI wouldn't be surprised. I attended the neighboring SF State and it's bad over there too. Many people fail out of the CS 101 course (including aspiring CS majors), and the Calculus 1 course offerings all the time. What I find more troubling however, is that we have a significant portion of the student body failing and retaking remedial Algebra I and II classes (to the point where sections for those two classes alone outnumber pretty much all other math classes -- despite Calc and Stats courses being required for everybody), and that many have a similarly hard time meeting even the basic English requirements to graduate. This is a serious problem that goes well beyond the supposed student 'laziness' theory that's so popular here on HN. Clearly our lower levels of education are screwing students up. Most of the students that get into college are seriously ill-prepared, and universities have taken it upon themselves to compensate for this by offering several remedial courses and lowering grading standards. It may be tempting to suggest that universities just stop doing this, but we've got to remember that our society values that degree way too much to ever let them get away with that (just imagine the revolt if all the colleges across the country started drastically lowering their acceptance rates). This sort of mindless degree-worship is silly on it's own, but it allows universities to grab money from otherwise under-qualified students, and who's gonna make a peep about that?
- nazgulnarsil 13y agoI think it's pretty common for schools to intentionally use some lower level courses as washout courses to avoid wasting resources on someone who won't be able to cut it at the upper division. Remember that STEM degrees cost the university significantly more as well. Calc II, E&M, and the first algorithms course all have very high failure rates.
- tlrobinson 13y agoI'm surprised there's no mention of the San Jose State professors who came out against MOOCs a few months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5644421 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5644421 http://www.mercurynews.com/education/ci_23320596/online-education-debate-san-jose-state-professors-see http://www.mercurynews.com/education/ci_23320596/online-educ... I'm sure this is entirely unrelated...
- microtherion 13y agoA 83% completion rate is actually extremely high for a MOOC course, typical rates are less than 10%: http://www.katyjordan.com/MOOCproject.html http://www.katyjordan.com/MOOCproject.html Presumably, the fee charged led to many borderline cases sticking out the course, but then flunking the final.
- mililani 13y agoI just finished an online neuroanatomy class at SJSU this past week. This just goes to show how dumb the kids have become in California's school systems. I went back to school this past year to change careers into health care. I took a year of pre-reqs at a local community college, and then this class as a pre-req for my program. It is shockingly absurd how easy and dumbed down they make classes in California's lower echelon schools. They basically hand you everything you need to know on every test on a silver platter: you don't need to read the book; they give you a study guide and EXPLICITLY tell you what will and will not be on the test; they sometimes will outright give you the exam questions, and students STILL screw that up. I took an abnormal psychology class where the instructor gave EVERYONE the exam questions, and students STILL did not show up for the exam or got questions wrong. I was like, HOW THE HELL IS THIS EVEN HAPPENING???!?! I don't find this system of learning at fault. I find the students at fault. I think they should fail these kids as a costly lesson: study or lose out on $2000 bones. Bunch of nit wits.
- stdbrouw 13y ago> I took an abnormal psychology class where the instructor gave EVERYONE the exam questions, and students STILL did not show up for the exam or got questions wrong. This may not be what happened in your situation, but giving students every possible exam question – with the caveat that there's a ton of them and they have open-ended answers – is actually a really smart thing to do. Anyone who wants to pass the exam will spend an inordinate amount of time crafting the perfect answers (either by themselves or in groups, which is fine) and then memorizing those. You could even say it gamifies the learning process, as every day of study you're keen to get through as many questions as possible. It's almost like being asked to write a 100 mini-essays. You end up learning more, not less.
- mililani 13y agoI wish that were true. The questions required simple one word or one sentence answers. It was absurd.
- rimantas 13y agoI am not from US and I can be very wrong, but can it be that things like this are the result of "feel good, don't offend anybody" attitude?
- Fuxy 13y agoI would like to see how many students represent the 44 to 24 percent. If it's a couple hundred I wouldn't consider it failure. Plus has anybody considered the fact that some people (like me) consider exams just way for professors/everybody to keep stats on how the class is doing and me taking the exam doesn't help me at all with learning what i wanted to learn from the course. I have taken a lot of online courses because i was interested in the subject did the small tests sprinkled in because i found the vaguely useful never took the exams. I like the small details/intricacies being pointed out to me in the tests but I'm not going to bother remembering it all just the knowledge of it being there is enough I'll look up the details when i need it.
- jimhefferon 13y agoI often read statements on this site that are like "I'm a super-motivated, highly-performing driven person and I ought to be able to take Artificial Intelligence from the Google Director of Search Technology and get credit for that", with which I agree entirely. But I teach at a college that is good but not (by various measures) first tier. I've been teaching for more than 30 years, and I teach Calculus, and while I have many students who do well, the majority of my folks find Calc to be hard, very hard. So I perceive from the statement in the first paragraph that many HN readers may have some trouble understanding who is in these seats. Perhaps half of the people in my class would have trouble writing down, say, what an arctangent is. An even larger issue, it seems to me, is that they do not have enough experience to know whether or not they understand something. They are not incapable dopes, but for instance if you go over homework numbers 11, 13, 15, and 17 and say "Do you understand?" they will nod. But you often find that if you ask them to do number 19, their pencil just hovers over the page. I see a couple of notes that argue something like "Well, they were given the opportunity .." but that is too hard a line, for me, personally. They are good people but they need support or guidance, over a medium-term period. TLDR: for first-rate performers this is great stuff. For the middle of the bell curve, not so much.
- nudetayne 13y agoI don't know anything about your classes except for what's in your post, but in my experience, most teachers who have this opinion of their students are usually not aware that it may be their teaching style that results in basic math classes being "hard". That teaching style typically boils down to regurgitating what the book already provides, which isn't what students need. I've also found that teachers who use that methodology don't actually know the subject matter terribly well outside of whatever cookie-cutter textbook is being used.
- danso 13y agoCan you clarify exactly what your experience is?
- jimhefferon 13y agoYou are mistaken. Calculus is hard.
- ZanyProgrammer 13y agoI'm not sure if people realize (in general) how difficult online courses are in general, compared to in person classes. Not everyone is an aspiring hacker who is smart and disciplined and posts on HN. Online classes have long been shown to be more difficult than their in person counterparts.
- mathattack 13y agoOne could say that 22-44% is actually a much higher pass rate than most MOOCs, and this was a success. It's just that the school is stuck in an old way of thinking. What's wrong with using on-line courses to see where people stand out? Perhaps let them avoid Fs on their report card if they drop out soon enough. (This is true for many normal classes too) Designed right, the feedback mechanisms should empower the middle tier students too.
- johnohara 13y agoAP Computer Science is supposed to be a college-level Intro to Computer Science for high school students. In 2012, 26,103 AP CS students took the exam. 63.6% received a "3" or above, meaning colleges accepting AP scores probably awarded credit. It also means 36.4% probably didn't receive credit. A "3" sits on the bubble. Since AP scores are "recommendations of proficiency", not final exam grades in the traditional sense, students with "3's" are often advised to reconsider taking the course again. It depends on the school of course, but nobody complains. That's how it works. Adding the 15.6% of students with a "3" to the 36.4% means 52% of students might not be "proficient" by definition. The San Jose State numbers aren't shocking, they're about right given the total population. Plus, looking at the courses and the material, I'm willing to bet 40% drop the traditional class before the final anyway. Are they included in SJSU's comparative statistic?