4 ms·
Massively over-simplifying, the price of shares is what the last trade was at. So it does not require a high volume to change the price - just buyers and selle
by btilly 13y ago
Massively over-simplifying, the price of shares is what the last trade was at. So it does not require a high volume to change the price - just buyers and sellers agreeing on a different value.
And what is that value? The value of a share is the market's best estimate of the present value of the future revenue earned from owning that share. Those earnings can happen from dividends, stock buybacks, a takeover bid, etc. But fundamentally they are an estimate of future profits.
So why does it move so fast? If you tell me that a major metric, the revenue/ad, dropped 5% and all else held the same, unless you have a good explanation for the anomaly, my simplest estimates of your future revenue just dropped 5%. If I am afraid that the drop could be a long-term trend, my estimates might drop further. If I believe that the metric has reasons to recover, my estimates might drop less.
But the natural tendency is to base estimates of future revenue on current rates of revenue. So a one quarter drop in current revenue results in a corresponding drop in share price. (And vice versa.)
- anonymfus 13y agoBTW Google don't pay dividends and promises to don't pay "in the foreseeable future". http://investor.google.com/corporate/faq.html#toc-dividend http://investor.google.com/corporate/faq.html#toc-dividend
- btilly 13y agoThis is true. However 5 years ago the same could be said for a number of other tech companies including CISCO, Oracle, and Apple. Yet all have since paid dividends or done stock buybacks. The market operates under the assumption that all other companies that stay profitable long enough will eventually do the same. And as long as management is seen as competent, is indifferent about whether "eventually" comes tomorrow or 20 years from now. For an extreme example, the markets have long rewarded Berkshire Hathaway for its growth in profits, even though no money was returned in any way to investors for 40 years. (There has since been a small buyback.)
- dlokshin 13y agoI think that when a founder is no longer at the helm, companies have to do more mainstream things when it comes to appealing to wall street.
- btilly 13y agoThis is exactly what happened with Apple. Wall St doesn't mind if it takes 5 years or 50. As long as they know how to crunch the figures for current value, and can speculate about future revenue.
- bdonlan 13y agoDon't forget that employee stock compensation also involves repurchasing shares off the market - which means some of the company's earnings do make it back to investors.
- btilly 13y agoActually I will try to forget that, because it is wrong. Many companies have the ability to cover employee stock compensation by issuing more shares. This dilutes existing ownership rather than returning value to investors. If you want your eyes to glaze over, http://www.sec.gov/rules/final/33-8048.htm http://www.sec.gov/rules/final/33-8048.htm describes the SEC rules for how public companies need to tell their investors (who also generally own the company) what the risks are that their share of the company will diminish due to new stock being created for things like employee incentive plans. Of course if you're an investor, your eyes shouldn't glaze over. Because we're talking large sums of money. For instance for Google in Q1 of 2013, we're talking something like $697 million of value transferred from existing investors to employees. (Search for "SBC" in http://investor.google.com/earnings/2013/Q1_google_earnings.html http://investor.google.com/earnings/2013/Q1_google_earnings.... to see where I pulled that figure from. I won't guarantee that I read the filing correctly though.)
- cmbaus 13y agoDividends are only one way to value to companies. If Apple fired everyone tomorrow and stopped selling products, their stock would still have value because of the cash (and real estate, etc) they have on the books. Buffet basically assumes that he is a better investor than his shareholders and by not paying taxes twice (corporate and individual) on dividends he will do better investing the profits and growing book value than his shareholders. Pretty good assumption so far.