5 ms·
As a biologist and chemist studying cancer, this sounds an awful like the "ontology recapitulates phylogeny" theory which, while a cute just-so story, turns out
by btilly 13y ago
As a biologist and chemist studying cancer, this sounds an awful like the "ontology recapitulates phylogeny" theory which, while a cute just-so story, turns out to be a particularly misleading way of looking at developmental biology.
It is misleading, but with a small kernel of truth that appears in the article.
That kernel is that there is little evolutionary pressure to cause changes in early development, and huge potential consequences to adjustment there, so early development is remarkably stable across many species. And this conservation goes right down to the genetic level. Thus it is wrong that we trace out our evolutionary heritage, however it is true that there are similarities between early development of distant species, and that commonality is due to conserved genes that evolved a very long time ago.
(There is, of course, another commonality. And that is the observation due to Gould in Ontogeny and Phylogeny that a lot of the raw material for evolution comes from altering the timing and rates of existing development processes, rather than from introducing "new" features.)
- dnautics 13y agoThat cancer is predominantly not "just" a mutagenic defect but that it more specifically recruits developmental controls and make them go go awry is relatively new in biology, but not revolutionary.
- btilly 13y agoAgreed. That said, the idea of targeting characteristic differences that show up when those controls are turned off was somewhat novel to me. But I'm not in the field, and that might be old hat as well.
- beagle3 13y agoCan you quantify "relatively new"? It was clear to me 10 years ago, and I thought it was common knowledge, but then everyone I talked to (especially people from medicine and biology) called it "an novel, interesting theory" when I talked about it (and had to explain why that would make sense). If there's a name or reference for this theory, I would appreciate a link. [ My argument that gets the "novel and interesting" theory remark is that in many cases cancer becomes "chemo resistant" after much shorter than any multicellular organism would -- thus, it can't just be a random mutagenic defect, and must involve non trivial developmental/evolutionary machinery. I don't remember where I picked it up, and it might have had a different form, but it was over 10 years ago ]
- dnautics 13y agoyeah, that's probably about right. I had first started hearing about it 3 years into grad school (i.e. 6 years ago), and I wasn't really a biologist with an interest in oncology until recently.