3 ms·
No, all suspensions are not fluids. Amorphous rocks, for an example, often contain microcrystals in suspension. They will not flow under any circumstances. Glas
by samatman 13y ago
No, all suspensions are not fluids. Amorphous rocks, for an example, often contain microcrystals in suspension. They will not flow under any circumstances. Glass can have all sorts of powders suspended in it, and is not a fluid.
Pitch can be proven to be a suspension via distillation. To prove it's a fluid, it must be observed to flow, to form a droplet, and to detach that droplet in the manner of a fluid.
- ColinWright 13y agoMathematician here. Yes, this is about to be a nitpick, and I apologize in advance. However: > No, all suspensions are not fluids. I think what you mean is "No, not all suspensions are fluids." Interpreting what you said literally would imply that anything that is a suspension is definitely not a fluid. And I know one can interpret what you said according to common sense to deduce that you didn't mean that, and that since some suspensions definitely are fluids, then you must have meant that there are suspensions that are not fluids. But this is about science, and where possible, I believe we should be precise. I believe it matters.
- blahedo 13y agoLinguist here.[0] Yes, this is a nitpick, but no apologies, because this is Hacker News. :) Unfortunately, languages don't always work the way that logicians would like them to do. Yes, we can read that sentence as the English-language summary of a logical formula (something like ∀x [Sx -> ¬Fx]), but English (and many other languages) treat the scope of the "not" as ambiguous. It's not a matter of "interpreting what you said literally", because there are multiple correct literal interpretations of what he said---he is not using a metaphor or anything. There are many cases where "not" can scope out to an enclosing quantifier (one of the better-known is "All that glitters is not gold", famously by Tolkien), and this is not just because all these speakers are in error. [0] Also computer scientist, but I'll wear my linguist hat for now.
- ok_craig 13y agoThe mathematician had a better point.
- Zuider 13y agoFor me, It violates the principle of least surprise to encounter a sentence like "all birds do not fly". I have to do a double take and reinterpret the sentence to realise its intended meaning.
- andrewflnr 13y agoIMO, if "all these speakers" collectively make the language ambiguous, then clearly someone is in error, because unambiguity[0] is essential to the primary purpose of language: communication. This has nothing to do with whether one is a logician or mathematician. A sentence like "all X are not Y" naturally associates like "all X are (not Y)". Usually modifiers attach to the closest thing they can, as a matter of well-established convention. So if someone decides they want that to mean "not (all X are Y)" and expects me to understand it, I'm going to go ahead and say they're the one in error. Sorry, Tolkien. [0] Is that a word? Chromium spell-check doesn't like it. I have lightened up on neologisms, as long as it's clear what they mean.
- DrewAllyn 13y agoDespite the primary purpose of languages being communication, they occasionally fail at it. Does this surprise you? Have you never heard someone say something and completely misinterpreted them?
- Tomte 13y agoAmbiguity does exist in natural languages, and it is obviously no big problem.[1] Unfortunately, technically inclined people like to apply their domain specific "knowledge" (compiler cosntruction?) to everything and come to incredibly bad conclusions. Ex falso quodlibet. It gets especially bad when technical guys talk about law and juristic methodology. Demonstrated daily here on HN. [1] BTW, linguistics is descriptive, not prescriptive. You immediately disqualify yourself from any linguistic discussion when you claim that native speakers are in error.
- samatman 13y agoThe question was "are all suspensions fluids"? My answer was "No, all suspensions are not fluids". The structure depended from the phrasing of the question.
- ColinWright 13y agoThe question asked if all X are Y. You want to assert that there are some X that are not Y. You can retain the original structure, and be correct according to the strict logic, by saying: Not all X are Y. or Some X are not Y. If someone came along with no knowledge of the field and read your statement: "all suspensions are not fluids." then it would be reasonable for them to deduce that for every suspension they looked at, it would not be a fluid. This is false.