5 ms·
> The Segway was demonstrably inferior to commonplace alternatives on simple metrics alone: speed, capacity, cost, safety, comfort. Metrics are like statistics
by stcredzero 13y ago
> The Segway was demonstrably inferior to commonplace alternatives on simple metrics alone: speed, capacity, cost, safety, comfort.
Metrics are like statistics, in that they can also mislead. It's really about the experience in specific contexts.
> It was only hyped because it was "cool".
Actually, it failed because it just looked dorky. (Which Steve Jobs predicted in his secret meeting with Dean Kamen.) Good tech badly marketed sometimes still doesn't sell.
- salemh 13y agoI believe this is what you are referring to: http://hbswk.hbs.edu/archive/3533.html http://hbswk.hbs.edu/archive/3533.html "What does everyone think about the design?" asked Doerr, switching subjects. "What do you think?" said Jobs to Tim. It was a challenge, not a question. "I think it's coming along," said Tim, "though we expect—" "I think it sucks!" said Jobs. His vehemence made Tim pause. "Why?" he asked, a bit stiffly. "It just does." "In what sense?" said Tim, getting his feet back under him. "Give me a clue." "Its shape is not innovative, it's not elegant, it doesn't feel anthropomorphic," said Jobs, ticking off three of his design mantras. "You have this incredibly innovative machine but it looks very traditional." The last word delivered like a stab. ... "Screw the lead times. You don't have a great product yet! I know burn rates are important, but you'll only get one shot at this, and if you blow it, it's over."
- stcredzero 13y agoThat's exactly it.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoDorky was just the icing on top, the reason why it failed was practicality. It cost many times more than even high end bicycles, without being faster, without being able to be used on streets, without having as much cargo capacity, and while depriving you of exercise. It cost many times more than a scooter, while being slower, having far less range, less cargo capacity, and not being usable on streets. And so on. If it had cost $200 it might have had a chance to find a niche, but at $3k or so it's just a toy.
- stcredzero 13y agoIt cost many times more than even high end bicycles, without being faster, without being able to be used on streets, without having as much cargo capacity, and while depriving you of exercise. It cost many times more than a scooter, while being slower, having far less range, less cargo capacity, and not being usable on streets. What you are saying highlights the reason it failed, while missing the point of the device. It was not for the bicycle use case. It was not meant to be faster or to be used on the streets. You can carry a couple of modest panniers worth of cargo, and touring-bike loads would again be besides the point. It was meant to deprive you of exercise. The Segway was meant to create a "new" use case and market segment in the same way that the iPhone and iPad did. (You can find plenty of objections analogous to the ones you list for the iPhone and iPad.) In that kind of context, dorky is going to kill you. at $3k or so it's just a toy. What Steve Jobs understood was that it's okay to start out as a toy when creating a new market segment. However, you have to be cool enough while being cheap enough. The Segway had a too high a price point and a too low of a cool factor.