6 ms·
Chemist here. We use centrifuging to separate components of a suspension by weight. Pitch is a suspension. The heavy stuff would drop to the outside, the visco
by samatman 13y ago
Chemist here. We use centrifuging to separate components of a suspension by weight.
Pitch is a suspension. The heavy stuff would drop to the outside, the viscosity would be affected, no experiment.
- samatman 13y agoIndeed, it occurs to me that one reason to keep watching the experiment is to see whether heavy pitch migrated to the bottom. If so, the rate should speed up in a few hundred years, assuming the hermetic seal is good and nothing is volatilizing off the top. This is unlikely, however. Many suspensions have a critical pressure below which they simply will not settle. Homogenized milk, for a familiar example.
- robomartin 13y ago> Chemist here. We use centrifuging to separate components of a suspension by weight. Pitch is a suspension. The last bit is puzzling: Are all suspensions fluids? And all fluids are viscous (even non-newtonian)? If so, why do we need an experiment to prove that pitch --a suspension-- is a fluid and is viscous? On the point of using a centrifuge. Is there something particularly special about gravity on earth that does not affect pitch? In other words, if we exposed pitch to 0.1x, 1x, 10x, 100x and 1000x g, at what point would the fundamental characteristics of the material invalidate the experiment. Are fluids and their viscosity only defined on earth (ignoring thermal and other non-gravitational effects)? Perhaps pitch is a viscous fluid on earth but a solid on the moon, where gravity is 1/6 of ours? Is this experiment only valid at 9.8 m/s^2 then? What's the tolerance based on the substance under test?
- samatman 13y agoNo, all suspensions are not fluids. Amorphous rocks, for an example, often contain microcrystals in suspension. They will not flow under any circumstances. Glass can have all sorts of powders suspended in it, and is not a fluid. Pitch can be proven to be a suspension via distillation. To prove it's a fluid, it must be observed to flow, to form a droplet, and to detach that droplet in the manner of a fluid.
- ColinWright 13y agoMathematician here. Yes, this is about to be a nitpick, and I apologize in advance. However: > No, all suspensions are not fluids. I think what you mean is "No, not all suspensions are fluids." Interpreting what you said literally would imply that anything that is a suspension is definitely not a fluid. And I know one can interpret what you said according to common sense to deduce that you didn't mean that, and that since some suspensions definitely are fluids, then you must have meant that there are suspensions that are not fluids. But this is about science, and where possible, I believe we should be precise. I believe it matters.
- blahedo 13y agoLinguist here.[0] Yes, this is a nitpick, but no apologies, because this is Hacker News. :) Unfortunately, languages don't always work the way that logicians would like them to do. Yes, we can read that sentence as the English-language summary of a logical formula (something like ∀x [Sx -> ¬Fx]), but English (and many other languages) treat the scope of the "not" as ambiguous. It's not a matter of "interpreting what you said literally", because there are multiple correct literal interpretations of what he said---he is not using a metaphor or anything. There are many cases where "not" can scope out to an enclosing quantifier (one of the better-known is "All that glitters is not gold", famously by Tolkien), and this is not just because all these speakers are in error. [0] Also computer scientist, but I'll wear my linguist hat for now.
- ok_craig 13y agoThe mathematician had a better point.
- Zuider 13y agoFor me, It violates the principle of least surprise to encounter a sentence like "all birds do not fly". I have to do a double take and reinterpret the sentence to realise its intended meaning.
- andrewflnr 13y ago
- samatman 13y agoTo answer your second question, there is some critical number, which we do not know empirically, after which pressure will separate pitch. We could apply some higher acceleration for a shorter time, but that acceleration would have to be highly consistent, and there is no way to shorten the experiment enough to keep that equipment from being unproductive to even contemplate. Sometimes patience really is the best answer.
- robomartin 13y agoOK, had a break so I looked around a little to see what I could learn [1], [2], [3] and [4] are my launching points. So I read that asphalt is actually a colloid and that pitch is not the same as asphalt. The Wikipedia page on pitch [3] says it is a "viscoelastic polymer". So I have to ask. Can a polymer be a suspension or a colloid on its own or is pitch a polymer colloid in another "host" substance? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspension_(chemistry) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspension_(chemistry) [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asphalt http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asphalt [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pitch_(resin) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pitch_(resin) [4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colloids http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colloids
- samatman 13y agoPitch is also a colloidal suspension, or colloid. The various polymers that make it up are not of equal weight, and there are little bits of graphite in there too. The chemistry of pitch is by no means simple, destructive distillation can go in many directions.
- robomartin 13y agoLearned a lot through this thread. Thanks.
- timdellinger 13y agoJust letting a suspension sit on the laboratory bench does the same thing: gravity separates the components by density (not weight). That's why you stir paint before you use it: it has partially separated, and has done so without the without the use of a centrifuge.
- samatman 13y agoIt is in fact density, although in my defense I meant molecular weight. But was still wrong ;-) However, there are many suspensions which will never settle under standard gravity, but which will rapidly settle in a centrifuge. We call these colloids.