4 ms·
Why would anyone pick POP, other than as a poor-man's SMTP replacement for picking up mail off some other server and dumping it into another IMAP or other serve
by zdw 13y ago
Why would anyone pick POP, other than as a poor-man's SMTP replacement for picking up mail off some other server and dumping it into another IMAP or other server-side mailbox system?
- toble 13y agoIf you don't like the idea of the 'cloud' and you check your email from a single device then POP's ideal - just depends on your requirements. I use IMAP though.
- jerf 13y agoIMAP can be used that way, too, so as far as I can tell it fully subsumes all practical POP use cases. (Perhaps there's some quirky case, whoknows, but let the people with the quirky cases worry about it.)
- jve 13y agoYou cannot track mail in Microsoft Dynamics CRM 2011 from their Outlook plugin if you don't use POP3. Because the plugin can only track messages from default .pst file, but if I remember correctly, I coulndn't set IMAP data file as the default one.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tokenizerrr 13y agoThat sounds like it's a problem with Microsoft Dynamics CRM or their Outlook plugin, not IMAP.
- reflectiv 13y agoI agree...however it is still an issue one might take into account when deciding which protocol to use.
- nhebb 13y agoI use POP with the "leave a copy on the server" option. Why would I do this? 1. I use Gmail apps for business, but unlike many people, I don't like the Gmail UI. I use a desktop client most of the time. 2. With Gmail + pop, I always have access to my email, but I can also make localized backups from my desktop client. 3. I don't trust that Gmail will retain my data forever or that I would never lose access to my account. I'm not paranoid about Google, but ultimately it's my responsibility to backup my mail data, not theirs.
- aroch 13y agoThe same thing can be done with IMAP
- tlrobinson 13y agoIMAP clients can backup your email locally as well...
- koralatov 13y agoI think the problem with IMAP, for a lot of users, is that many clients don't keep a complete local copy of your e-mail store by default, and they don't realise that it can do that.
- koralatov 13y agoYou might find it worthwhile to look into OfflineIMAP[1] --- it offers a POP-ish experience whilst still retaining the advantages of IMAP. [1]: http://offlineimap.org/ http://offlineimap.org/
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- GrantS 13y agoI use POP because of inertia: When I first set up a Gmail account in 2004, I tried IMAP and it behaved in unexpected ways when organizing mail locally with my other POP accounts, so I switched it to POP and have never really had a reason to revisit that decision. If I recall correctly, moving an IMAP email message into a local directory that the IMAP account didn't know about deleted it from the server, which I did not want. But I had this huge local organizational structure for all my emails from multiple accounts, so I could either choose to exclude Gmail from this organization, reconfigure everything so that my brand-new, unproven Gmail account was the master account that controlled everything, or just turn on Gmail's POP mode and maintain the status quo. Honest question: If I have multiple email accounts, some of which are IMAP and some of which are POP, that I organize with a mail client on my local machine into directories that mix mail from all the accounts (is it even possible?), then if I change the directory structure on the server of one of the IMAP accounts, what is supposed to happen to my local directory structure and all the non-IMAP-mail or IMAP-mail-from-other-accounts, that used to be in those directories?