4 ms·
I respect your views and comments and the above is correct and mournful and valid. But it suffers from something too common around here - dispassion. Looking a
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
I respect your views and comments and the above is correct and mournful and valid.
But it suffers from something too common around here - dispassion. Looking at the wider, geopolitical implications, a step back from the facts and keeping things on the level of "people" - not that person.
I read your comment first, then dived into the article. I expected to agree with you, but I just felt mounting horror, outrage and a realisation that things are beyond a line I never knew existed. So here is my comment
Jesus H Fucking Christ on a Stick! We are blowing up American Citizens sitting in cafes and legally it's "untouchable". Are we that fucking removed from reality that its ok to murder people with no trial or comeback. It seems its ok to blow away the son and grandson of other country's government ministers and not expect a war, a prison sentence, or even a mention on CNN
Are we that fragile as a civilisation that the tiny amount of damage terrorism presents is actually a threat? What did I miss - I thought we had industry, welfare, science and ingenuity. Stop murdering people.
I am writing to my MP but mostly I would like some figures - there was a twitter thing that reported gun murders. Can we do the same for drone murders?
- cinger 13y agohttp://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/ http://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/ they have an amazing datastore of all of the known drone strikes http://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/category/projects/drones/ http://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/category/projects/drone... if you click into a specific country, they give detailed accounts of the events, like location, and how many dead, down to the number of civilians versus presumed militants, and also a detailed description of what occurred i remember reading of one where the drone bombed a shelter with presumed militants inside, one person survived, crawled out of the wreckage and began to run into the desert, the drone circled around and tracked and followed the man for twenty minutes as he ran away and finally shot him dead there are so many that I had to go into their archive to find the one spoken about in this article, and it is a very detailed account: YEM034 October 14 2011 ♦ 7-9 people killed, including 16-year and 17 year old boy ♦ 2 teenage children reported killed A second drone attack then struck either a vehicle or a restaurant area. PBS Frontline later filmed at the scene of the attack, the footage showing the ruined foundations of a small building along with a nearby crater. Abdel- Rahman Anwar al Awlaki, the 16-year old son of al-Awlaki, died... the article is written by NASSER al-AWLAKI... Also initially reported killed was militant Ibrahim al-Bana. Doubts have since been raised about al-Bana’s death. A statement from Abdel-Rahman’s family read, ‘he left with some friends for dinner under the moonlight when an American missile landed, killing Abdel-Rahman and his friends‘. In a separate statement, the family said: ’On October 14th, 2011 Abdulrahman, along with some of his tribe’s youth have gone barbecuing under the moonlight. A drone missile hit their congregation killing Abdulrahman and several other teenagers’. A second teenager and family member, Ahmed Abdel-Rahman al-Awlaki, 17, is known to have died. Five to seven others were also killed, including Sarhan al-Qusa (aka Farhan al Quso) brother of AQAP leader Fahd al-Qusa or Quso, according to a member of Awlaki’s tribe. Reuters later claimed that the dead men were planning to renounce al Qaeda before they were killed. Elders claimed that four other Awlaki tribal members died in the strike. Two weeks after the strike, AQAP released leaflets stating that Ibrahim al-Bana had not been killed. Ansar al-Sharia also reported in its second October newsletter that Bana’s death was ‘a lie’. In a statement, Yemen security officials said the air strike was among five that targeted al Qaeda positions in Shabwa, adding that al-Bana was wanted internationally for planning attacks both inside and outside Yemen. ‘He was one of the group’s most dangerous operatives,’ it said. The Washington Post reported that it was JSOC rather than the CIA which carried out the attack: When pressed on why the CIA had not pulled the trigger, US officials said it was because the main target…an Egyptian named Ibrahim al-Banna, was not on the agency’s kill list. The Awaki teenager, a US citizen with no history of involvement with al Qaeda, was an unintended casualty. In interviews, senior US officials acknowledged that the two kill lists don’t match, but offered conflicting explanations as to why. In April 2012 the Toronto Star featured an interview with Nasser al-Awalaki, grandfather of Abdel-Rahman and former Yemen government minister. In it he said that former Yemen President Saleh had sent him a message insisting that he had had no role in his grandson’s death: ‘Tell Dr. Nasser I swear to God that I have nothing to do with the killing of his son.’Nasser al-Awlaki also said he would be taking legal action: ‘I am only a university professor and I’m not the kind of guy who would enlist tribal people. My only chance now is to go to court and I hope as far as Abdulrahman at least, they will be fair to us. They cannot claim he’s collateral damage.’ In April 2013 Jeremy Scahill added further controversy to the attack, reporting: A former senior official in the Obama administration told me that after Abdulrahman’s killing, the president was “surprised and upset and wanted an explanation.” The former official, who worked on the targeted killing program, said that according to intelligence and Special Operations officials, the target of the strike was al-Banna, the AQAP propagandist. “We had no idea the kid was there. We were told al-Banna was alone,” the former official told me. Once it became clear that the teenager had been killed, he added, military and intelligence officials asserted, “It was a mistake, a bad mistake.” However, John Brennan, at the time President Obama’s senior adviser on counterterrorism and homeland security, “suspected that the kid had been killed intentionally and ordered a review. I don’t know what happened with the review.”‘ And in May 2013 US Attorney-General Eric Holder told US lawmakers Abdulrahman was ‘not specifically targeted by the United States’. In a letter, Holder explained Anwar al Awlaki was a legitimate target and that ‘[US] citizenship alone does not make such individuals immune from being targeted’. He said three other US citizens, including Abdulrahman, had been killed by US drones during Obama’s presidency. Abdulrahman’s grandfather discusses his death in a July 2012 interview for ACLU and CCR Type of action: Air assault, drone strike Location: Azan, Shabwa References: CNN, GlobalPost, Business Insider, Yemen Post, ABC, AFP (via Taiwan News), Reuters,Press TV, AP, Washington Post, Long War Journal, LA Times, Reuters, Yemen Post, Time Magazine, Antiwar.com, Empty Wheel, Salon, Al-Awlaki family statement, EmptyWheel, Toronto Star, PBS Frontline, CNN, The Nation (US), Department of Justice i was first turned onto this site[1] from an app that attempted to text you every time a new drone strike was posted to this site, the APPL app store refused its submission a number of times citing "The features and/or content of your app were not useful or entertaining enough" .[1]. http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2012/08/drone-app/ http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2012/08/drone-app/
- cinger 13y agoThe individual country pages are listed on the right under causality estimates, click a time frame for a list of all of the accounts, Somalia: http://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/2012/02/22/get-the-data-somalias-hidden-war/ http://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/2012/02/22/get-the-data... Pakistan: http://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/2013/01/03/obama-2013-pakistan-drone-strikes/ http://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/2013/01/03/obama-2013-p... Yemen: http://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/2013/01/03/yemen-reported-us-covert-actions-2013/ http://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/2013/01/03/yemen-report...
- yaddayadda 13y ago[i was first turned onto this site[1] from an app that attempted to text you every time a new drone strike was posted to this site, the APPL app store refused its submission a number of times citing "The features and/or content of your app were not useful or entertaining enough"] This is one of the big reasons I went with Android - I don't want to be blocked from doing what I define as "useful or entertaining" on my own hardware. [To be clear - I'm not saying Android is perfect, secure, private or anything else.]
- Terretta 13y agoIf Forecast.io can show you real time weather radar through an HTML5 app installed to your home screen (the type of 100% open app Jobs originally said the iPhone was made for), surely drone strikes wouldn't be so hard.
- swombat 13y agoSeems to me like the horrendous part is the bit where you take a citizen, accuse them of terrorism, stick them on a "kill list" (wtf!), then execute them without further due process of law. Bear in mind that "terrorism" now covers people like an 82-year old catholic nun demonstrating at a nuclear plant. If that's not anti-constitutional, your constitution ain't worth shit. If it is anti-constitutional, your system of "checks and balances" ain't worth shit. Either way something fundamental is very broken there.
- ankitml 13y agoIt is not something, Government of USA is running lots of programs without any checks and balances necessary for a functional democracy. And surprisingly, this very govt is interested in bringing democracy to other countries.
- pygy_ 13y agoThere's a running joke about that. I feel weird linking to an image macro on HN, but it is sadly relevant. http://cdn.memegenerator.net/instances/250x250/34530200.jpg http://cdn.memegenerator.net/instances/250x250/34530200.jpg
- Theory5 13y agoYea, we liberate the SHIT out of other countries.
- jasonkolb 13y agoI would also like to point out that merely taking a video of animals is now--according to utah--an act that transforms you into a terrorist. The abuses have only just begun. Http://m.deseretnews.com/article/865550866/House-passes-bill-to-stop-animal-rights-terrorists--shooting-video-on-farms.html?pg=all [Edit: Utah's house, not the US congress]
- CrazedGeek 13y agoI would like to point out that that was the Utah House, not the United States Congress. (EDIT: In case this looks like an argument it isn't, parent's comment originally referred to "our congress".)
- igravious 13y agoThe reason given is that these people are designated 'enemy combatants' or 'terrorists' so a different set of rules apply to them†. Effectively since this is a War on Terror and because terror can come from anywhere and strike anywhere the entire planet is a battlefield because the reach of the US military and paramilitary apparatus is global. Glenn Greenwald has written[1] many excellent articles about this long before Mr. Snowden came along. Once the whole world is a battlefield then everyone is on the field of battle. Interestingly enough it takes congress to declare war so in effect what we've had here is a very blatant power grab[2], an invocation of emergency procedures in the name of National Security. How aptly the National Security Agency seems named now, don't you think. Obviously there is the TIDE[3] list that gets people restricts their right of travel (no-fly lists - (I wonder does this cover getting on a boat or is it just that specific mode of international travel - (thank you for reading this far))). But there must also be a shorter "these people are really bad and must be taken out list" and that's what these people are on. Modulo the odd innocent bystander, and error be it human operator or machine or intelligence. So it's not murder, it's 21st century warfare and these are the enemy. That doesn't mean it doesn't stink to high hell. And if they was any justice in the world the people who set up and enable these unjust extra-judicial killings with there oh so pat cover story and layers and layers of secrecy upon secrecy would get their just desserts in turn. [1] http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/feb/05/obama-kill-list-doj-memo http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/feb/05/obama-ki... [2] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/naomi-wolf/ten-steps-to-close-down-a_b_46695.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/naomi-wolf/ten-steps-to-close-... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorist_Identities_Datamart_Environment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorist_Identities_Datamart_E... † it's not 'murder' when they do it
- cafard 13y ago"nterestingly enough it takes congress to declare war so in effect what we've had here is a very blatant power grab[2], an invocation of emergency procedures in the name of National Security." The United States has declare a very few wars and fought many more, of varying degrees of length and intensity.
- igravious 13y ago
- kaybe 13y agoIt actually sounds like state-sanctionend terrorism to me - hits people unexpectedly and for reasons they might have little control over, and fear is a major factor.
- crpatino 13y ago> Jesus H Fucking Christ on a Stick! We are blowing up American Citizens sitting in cafes and legally it's "untouchable". And I find appalling and outraging that in one sentence you managed to blaspheme against my God, imply that the lives of 6.8 billion of non-American human beings are worthless, and then add insult to injury by whining about the fact that sometimes you end up on the receiving end of own lack of collective moral compass. There are no words that can express how I feel about this, and at the same time are suitable for this fine audience.
- ihaveajob 13y agoYes, the different reaction of the general US audience depending on the nationality of the targets is quite saddening. It reminds me of TV interviews in Spain after some ETA killing, when a local would cry and scream because the victim was also a Basque, not an outsider, in which case all is cool. Nationalism is akin to racism.
- kanyang 13y agohttps://twitter.com/dronestream https://twitter.com/dronestream is a Twitter account that's reporting through the history of all US drone strikes. Here is an interview with Josh Begley, the man behind that account: http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2013/01/josh-begley-interview-on-dronestream-twitter-account.html http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2013/01/josh-begley-int...
- jami 13y agoThis is a good visualization of drone strikes in Pakistan: http://drones.pitchinteractive.com/ http://drones.pitchinteractive.com/ Edit: I don't completely love focusing on the technology behind killing innocent people in war. Whether the planes are piloted or not, people sitting in cafes, elementary schools, orphanages... get killed because we no longer arrest bad guys. We try to blow them up.
- rayiner 13y ago> We are blowing up American Citizens sitting in cafes and legally it's "untouchable". The crux of the debate is how much an "american citizen" can claim the protection of that citizenship while waging war against the U.S. and evading attempts to bring him to justice for a decade. Being an American citizen entitles you to due process. Not "a court trial no matter what the circumstances," but some level of process appropriate to the circumstances. > Stop murdering people. It's only murder when people who are part of the same social compact and subject to the same law kill each other. When one group of people organized into a state kills people in another group, that's not "murder" it's exercise of the sovereign right of nations.
- acjohnson55 13y ago> The crux of the debate is how much an "american citizen" can claim the protection of that citizenship while waging war against the U.S. and evading attempts to bring him to justice for a decade. This applies to Anwar Al-Awlaki himself, and even then the constitutionality of the killing seems highly suspect to me. But his son (the author's granson), Abdulrahman Al-Awlaki, was also killed by a drone strike in Yemen. Nobody has publicly stated a justification for Abdulrahman's death. He was simply an American citizen traveling in the country his family came from, as far as we know.
- tsotha 13y agoThey said he wasn't the target. I doubt they even knew who he was.
- rayiner 13y agoAl-Awlaki's son was killed in a different drone strike a month later targeting different Al Qaeda officials. I don't think he was the intended target. But when you're traveling with Al Qaeda that kind of shit happens, you know?
- tptacek 13y agoIt's a tough situation to parse. On the one hand, if you stipulate that the US is going to engage "Al Qaeda" militarily, drone strikes probably save many lives; every alternative, from manned airstrikes through cruise missiles through (God forbid) boots on the ground --- every alternative is empirically worse. On the other hand, the drone program in essence demands that the US conduct a long-running campaign of assassination. I might not have a moral problem with that in the specific case of actual, bona fide Al Qaeda personnel, but surely this can't be how we deal with all our adversaries moving forward?