3 ms·
> Whenever I watch a movie with some of my extended family, there's always someone who asks why the movie doesn't fill the entire screen. I'm seeing more and m
by stcredzero 13y ago
> Whenever I watch a movie with some of my extended family, there's always someone who asks why the movie doesn't fill the entire screen.
I'm seeing more and more things like this, which seem to fit into a category of "geometrical illiteracy." Making 4:3 video wider to "use the pixels" on a widescreen just looks wrong. It makes people look squatter than they actually are. Many diagrams and animations on Discovery channel shows that supposedly fall into the category of "science education" seem to be made by scientific illiterates. Apparently, the visual artists are looking up all of the terms in the script and description, but who have no real understanding of the underlying concepts. Wildly incorrect geometries are present in the majority of these.
A prime example. The a plane moving as in the animation shown would produce forces in the exact opposite direction!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ggP32UJeTHQ#t=865s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ggP32UJeTHQ#t=865s
If this is what a large fraction of human beings are like, how are we supposed to maintain a democratic and technological society?
- discodave 13y agoFor years all the pubs near me would show 4:3 TV sports broadcasts stretched to their widescreen TV's so all the players looked slightly fat. sigh.
- anigbrowl 13y agoIf this is what a large fraction of human beings are like, how are we supposed to maintain a democratic and technological society? ...yet another reason I've concluded that democracy is seriously overrated.
- stcredzero 13y agoThink of it as a kind of sacrificial metal. As it corrodes it prevents far worse corrosion. Totalitarian governments becoming corrupt cause an order of magnitude more damage per capita than rotting democracies.
- lotyrin 13y agoThank you for that concept. I'm going to go have a drink and hold my head for a bit, but it's definitely a useful way to think about it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- chrisrhoden 13y agoThat clip is from a show called, "Penn & Teller Tell a Lie," wherein they present lies (and one truth) as fact. Additionally, you probably misheard when Penn said, "centripetal force," and assumed he said, "centrifugal force." Probably not the, "prime example," you thought it was.
- stcredzero 13y ago> That clip is from a show called, "Penn & Teller Tell a Lie," wherein they present lies (and one truth) as fact. Additionally, you probably misheard when Penn said, "centripetal force," and assumed he said, "centrifugal force." Probably not the, "prime example," you thought it was. 1) If the plane would spin sound its own axis like that, the iced tea would have hit the canopy. The diagram is just wrong. 2) They presented several truths and one lie. Are you trolling by "telling a lie?" You would have completely mislead anyone who only took a casual glance at the video.