3 ms·
Every transfer for home video I've ever seen has been anamorphic widescreen since the earliest days of the DVD. There were a few releases among the very earlies
by smacktoward 13y ago
Every transfer for home video I've ever seen has been anamorphic widescreen since the earliest days of the DVD. There were a few releases among the very earliest DVDs that were pan-and-scan, because the studios were afraid people would freak out if they saw black bars on their TV. They didn't, so pan-and-scan vanished. And that was back when 4:3 SDTVs were the norm, now almost everyone has 16:9 sets, so widescreen transfers if anything would be more easily welcomed now.
Considering how much of their libraries they have now mastered for DVD, it would seem like it would take more work to go back and do a pan-and-scan transfer than it would to just reuse the one they made for widescreen DVD.
- toast0 13y agoI only have about 10 dvds, and I've got one that they encoded the black bars on instead of doing anamorphic (first region 1 release of Dune), and at least one 4:3 that was released in 2004 (Grind... I only have this as a result of a disturbing practice of giving horrible birthday gifts in my circle of friends)
- josteink 13y ago> Every transfer for home video I've ever seen has been anamorphic widescreen since the earliest days of the DVD. That's interesting because one of the things which disappointed me most with DVDs was how immensely hard it was to get DVDs with actual anamorphic widescreen. Most movies was actually fullscreen or letterboxed, and for 2.35:1 films that meant effectively 200 lines for film content. This was after DVDs had been on the market for 5+ years mind you. TLDR: An anecdote does not make facts nor data.
- wilg 13y agoAs dumb as it sounds, these masters that were made for DVD are oftentimes standard definition.
- smackfu 13y agoA lot of early DVDs were 4:3 letterboxed. On a 4:3 SDTV, they look the same as anamorphic widescreen. Sometimes better, on some of the old DVD players that did a bad job of downsizing.