4 ms·
The same Google whose new strategy - only two months ago -involved disabling the ability to use off-the-record on Gtalk by default in chat? Or using third-party
by dmix 13y ago
The same Google whose new strategy - only two months ago -involved disabling the ability to use off-the-record on Gtalk by default in chat? Or using third-party OTR plugins (with real encryption) by replacing gtalk XMPP with Google Hangout?
http://news.en.softonic.com/google-chat-history-can-no-longer-be-turned-off-by-default http://news.en.softonic.com/google-chat-history-can-no-longe...
> One of the features of Hangouts that was really emphasized at I/O, was that you will no longer have to worry about losing anything. Chats are kept, and everything you share, like photos, is put in folders and stored.
- superuser2 13y agoGoogle Hangout is substantially more functional than gtalk. For example, my Class of 2017 group does 10-way hangouts most weeks to get to know each other, something which really wasn't possible with gtalk, which facilitates one-way calls between contacts. Hangouts provides a semi-private room that more people can join, and all sorts of silly things to like watching YouTube together. It's not a conspiracy to prevent you from using encryption. That's just absurd. If you need XMPP and OTR, run Openfire on a VM. I just deployed this internally at work and we love it.
- ineedtosleep 13y agoFWIW, the Google Hangout(Talk) has an option to "Turn history off". Whether or not you trust that is a different story.
- jmillikin 13y agoThe complaint is that there used to be an option to make history off by default, which no longer exists. Every chat must have its history manually disabled.
- jmillikin 13y ago> Or using third-party OTR plugins (with real encryption) > by replacing gtalk XMPP with Google Hangout? Has this actually stopped working for you? On my account, Gtalk still works fine with XMPP, including OTR chats in Pidgin.
- dmix 13y agoXMPP is still supported for now in Gtalk. But Google is moving away from XMPP.
- rdtsc 13y ago> was that you will no longer have to worry about losing anything. Chats are kept, and everything you share, like photos, is put in folders and stored. Let us help you by monitoring you better and recording everything you do. For your convenience and protection of course. You know, I didn't like them. Now I despise them. They said that with a straight face. They could have just you know, not say anything, or say Facebook is doing all this stuff we can't fall behind we need this data on your because we want to target ads better or we have to comply with government regulations. That's fine. I understand that. But telling people how this is for their convenience is really demeaning.
- magicalist 13y ago> But telling people how this is for their convenience is really demeaning. I see your intention here, but I think you've stepped out of touch with the vast majority of users here, and I don't mean the "people just want to share their lives on facebook, privacy be damned" kind of way. "Chats are kept, and everything you share, like photos, is put in folders and stored" really is a feature that people want. Not being able to set a default for do/don't save all chat history should be fixed, but what you quote really is for convenience. I search over my gtalk history all the time, as just as much useful information is in there as is in my email. I don't use the Google+ picture auto-upload, but I do use the Dropbox one, so that all the pictures I take with my phone are automatically uploaded to my dropbox folder and available on all of my computers. Those things are really convenient, and I love not having to have to think about them; they're just there when I do need them. I don't see how that could be possibly construed as only motivated by ad revenue and government regulations. What needs to come along with those features: 1) easy to disable/enable with good granularity (per feature, per contact, altogether, etc) 2) possible to secure client-side if I want to 3) government needs to demonstrate probable cause to get warrant to get access to what is not secured client-side 4) I need to be notified within a reasonable amount of time of a warrant being served none of those things preclude these kinds of "nothing is ever lost" features.
- tracker1 13y ago3) Fisa's 3-hops rule just means that you have to have an acquaintance that has an acquaintance that has an acquaintance that is on some investigative list for said warrant to apply to you.