5 ms·
And this is why you shouldn't open source the core part of your business (looking at you DotCloud). Sure, Docker is good for the community. But it's also a key
by chatmasta 13y ago
And this is why you shouldn't open source the core part of your business (looking at you DotCloud). Sure, Docker is good for the community. But it's also a key competitive advantage for DotCloud. By giving away that advantage, they create opportunities for viable competitors.
- druiid 13y agoIndeed. I'm a bit curious as to why DotCloud released Docker? I mean, sure, someone was going to have an easy-to-use container system sooner or later, but for now that is one of the few defining features that DotCloud has going for them... although one of their competitors is successfully using a modified version of Cloud Foundry (AppFog).
- danielsiders 13y agoWe're been working with the DotCloud folks on the container problem since long before Docker was public. They've been very supportive of our efforts to build a full featured PaaS based on Docker and knew about it long before they released Docker publicly. They have their own strategy for their company and product, releasing Docker was a very intentional part of that.
- rglullis 13y agoBecause it's better to have a small slice of a market that you can compete on than nothing on a market that is dominated by other players. This supposed competitive advantage that they would have would mean nothing if they still had to work on top of other IaaS-providers. They would be undercut by the IaaS themselves. By changing the game, they get another angle to work from.
- shykes 13y agoHi, I'm the founder of dotCloud and author of Docker. Projects like Flynn are the reason we opened Docker in the first place. They are a good thing for the docker ecosystem, and they are definitely good for dotCloud. The dirty little secret of PaaS is that there is not, and will never be a single PaaS that fits everyone's needs. With docker we offer a foundation for many PaaSes to engage in a healthy competition while preserving interoperability. So Shopify will always be free to mix and match Flynn's lego bricks with the bricks of other offerings - because they are all Docker-compatible. The authors of Flynn get that, which is why I believe their product will be good and I will be personally sponsoring it :)
- oellegaard 13y agoYou have my deepest respect! I wish more people would think the same way.
- mwcampbell 13y agoAre you not concerned that once Flynn gets good enough, lots of companies will take a little time to get Flynn set up on VPSes or dedicated servers, rather than pay the high premium for dotCloud?
- danielsiders 13y agoFlynn is particularly appealing to companies that need to completely control their own infrastructure. In the same sense that git being open source helps, not hurts github, I think there's limited crossover between the users of Flynn and DotCloud customers.
- druiid 13y agoNot sure I completely agree with this. I don't know what your internal discussions were, but at least one of your competitors has an 'enterprise' option in which they give you your own version of the toolkit. Sadly among this was that they stopped with their open-source contributions to the Cloud Foundry community (Their last update appears to have been over two years ago https://github.com/cloudfoundry/vcap/pull/105 https://github.com/cloudfoundry/vcap/pull/105). I'm not complaining that an alternative to Cloud Foundry is going to exist, but I'm still a bit surprised.