3 ms·
In a proper free market they can't really do that, as I can buy a handset through operator A and immediately switch (with no penalties allowed) to a cheaper ope
by PeterisP 13y ago
In a proper free market they can't really do that, as I can buy a handset through operator A and immediately switch (with no penalties allowed) to a cheaper operator B.
If there is no legal/monopolistic lock-in like in USA (where the phone is locked to a certain operator), but instead operator B can jailbreak&unlock your phone for you when you switch, then you can't extract huge monthly prices just because you sold a phone 9 months ago.
- icebraining 13y agoPretty sure free markets are supposed to allow for contracts. "No penalties allowed" is clearly government regulation (one I happen to appreciate).
- PeterisP 13y agoYes, true. However, even with no regulation at all, you might owe some contract penalty, but you still be able to use that phone with any operator after contract expiry or breaking. The "zero point" of regulation would mean that any and all device restrictions can be freely legally broken and removed, which currently isn't the case in USA; in unregulated markets there are thriving legal businesses that do, for example, jailbreaks of phones that people bring in from USA, and which were subsidised there.
- emn13 13y agoI think the issue of contracts is somewhat orthogonal to a market. Of course you need to be able to deal, but the details of that aren't somehow fundamental to a market. The point of a market is to allow sufficient flexibility so that lots of individual actors can by trial and error find an efficient solution to a hard problem without requiring a benevolent genius at the center. How much flexibility is enough? How much is too much? I don't think there's a one-size fits all solution here, and the size discrepancy between the cellular provider and the individual user only makes it harder. Personally, I think that in most markets, but particular these kind of highly asymmetric ones, we'd see more innovation and progress if the market were more fluid; which suggests to me that the carrier (and handset provider) lock-in is not a good thing.