4 ms·
Yet another place where I feel a tinge of anger that VPNs utterly failed to deliver on the potential of private secure connectivity to personal data storage fro
by bhauer 13y ago
Yet another place where I feel a tinge of anger that VPNs utterly failed to deliver on the potential of private secure connectivity to personal data storage from anywhere. Several of us here at HN set up and manage home networks to which we connect over an encrypted channel. To us--well, to me at least--it seems plain as day that my device should allow me to backup its sensitive data to a file that I store on a file system of my choosing. I would store it on my encrypted disk array at home (which is then backed up to a data center disk array).
But to a layperson, the lack of a secure private channel to personal data storage remains an infeasibility. So laypeople embrace third-party "cloud" storage offerings, this one included. These services offer omnipresence of data. They don't offer personal control, but many people are willing to concede control because omnipresence is such a convenience.
Putting all of that aside, however, and accepting the world as it is, with VPNs the tragedy of user experience that they are... An open question remains: why not ask the user to create a passphrase for use in encrypting the device's data before storing it at the GoogleCloud + NSACloud?
The seemingly obvious answer to the rhetorical question is a worry about user experience pain ("woe is me, I need to remember another passphrase now"). So perhaps the user would be instructed to provide a passphrase if and only if they are concerned about their backup being stored on the NSACloud. If they are not concerned, they can leave the field empty.
- js2 13y agoBack to my Mac pretty seamlessly establishes an ipsec connection back to a time capsule or other Mac on your home network.
- ctb_mg 13y agoYes, but as far as backups and backup security is concerned -- a time capsule is fairly proprietary, and a Mac on your home network is susceptible to local catastrophe.