3 ms·
The larger Chinese-made chargers generally don't have these issues (though a few apparently do). Notice that this fake contains all or nearly all the component
by makomk 13y ago
The larger Chinese-made chargers generally don't have these issues (though a few apparently do).
Notice that this fake contains all or nearly all the components required to build a safe and working charger, including full safety isolation, fuse protection, and output regulation. The manufacturer's entirely capable of building one, they've just fatally compromised on safety in order to fit everything inside a tiny fake Apple shell.
(The blog post says it doesn't have a fuse, but generally instead of having a seperate fuse the input resistor on these power supplies is a special fusible resistor which is manufactured to also work as a fuse. Saves a few cents and some space at the cost of using a specialist component. Unfortunately it's impossible to tell it apart from a normal resistor just by looking.)
- coldtea 13y ago>The larger Chinese-made chargers generally don't have these issues (though a few apparently do). Hardly a re-assurance now, is it?
- moogleii 13y agoOnly electrocutes 5% of the time. What me worry?
- kens 13y agoAuthor here: it was a surprise to see this old article on HN. To reply to your comments, even if you fix the safety problems, this charger would generate really terrible power. They're using a primitive RCC circuit instead of spending a few cents on a controller IC, and they're using low-quality capacitors. I have oscilloscope traces at http://www.righto.com/2012/10/a-dozen-usb-chargers-in-lab-apple-is.html http://www.righto.com/2012/10/a-dozen-usb-chargers-in-lab-ap... that show the huge quality difference between a $2 charger, a good charger, and an excellent charger. I'm familiar with fusible resistors, and this charger doesn't have one. I've also torn apart the transformers from cheap chargers and the transformers are usually unsafe due to insufficient insulation. These cheap chargers cut corners everywhere. You're likely to have touchscreen problems while using one due to the poor power quality.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]