4 ms·
Of course he would. Big corporations can buy things and sell things, but they can't legally send out men with guns and dogs to simply take what they decide they
by jacques_chester 13y ago
Of course he would. Big corporations can buy things and sell things, but they can't legally send out men with guns and dogs to simply take what they decide they need.
There is a necessity for someone to have the men, guns and dogs -- even if they only figurative. But men with guns and dogs are dangerous and so whoever has them needs to be strictly controlled and supervised. The ability to acquire more such men, guns and dogs needs to be resisted as much as possible, because it is very hard to claw back.
- coldtea 13y ago>Of course he would. Big corporations can buy things and sell things, but they can't legally send out men with guns and dogs to simply take what they decide they need. No, they can just buy media to influence public opinion or buy politicians and influence policy, and have them send the men with guns. But I think we mostly agree with that. Only I don't think the solution is less government (a smaller government is even easier for big corporations to have power on), but more vigilant citizens participating in politics.
- jacques_chester 13y agoI personally suspect that there are no strategies that are stable over multiple generations. Otherwise one would have emerged. Basically that there is a kind of political thermodynamics that destroys all nations, no matter how great. Peter Turchin has developed an interesting family of theories about the rise and fall of great powers. He wrote a popular account, War and Peace and War, which I reviewed here: http://chester.id.au/2012/05/14/review-war-and-peace-and-war/ http://chester.id.au/2012/05/14/review-war-and-peace-and-war... As a footnote, I found why he used the term 'Asabiya'. It comes from an earlier historian, Ibn al-Khaldun.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoa smaller government is even easier for big corporations to have power on What makes you think so? Smaller government has smaller "attack surface", as hackers say.
- jbooth 13y agoThe most minimal government possible is reduced to just the scary parts. That's the thing. A smaller government is no less scary in a police/military sense, unless you actually make the military and police smaller. The irony is that everyone who goes on about a marginal tax increase, social security or some land-use regulations being tyranny, all of those same exact people are the biggest cheerleaders for a less restrained military.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoYou can downsize military as well. It's easier with smaller government because there is one person responsible, if they say we downsize military, we downsize it. Compare it with having a dozen of committees with everyone in it being mediocre and fearing change, fearing initiative, fearing that something will happen after the downsize. Committees are good at reacting (one loud incident -> wham you've got new regulations) and bad at acting (runaway project will run forever with nobody having balls to shut it down).
- jbooth 13y agoWoah, woah, so by smaller government, you mean dictatorship? How is that less threatening? Committees are what happens when you have a legislature.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoIt doesn't have to be a dictatorship. The more direct or trusted your democracy is, the less layers you need. You don't need committees to make decisions, you may use them to approve people who then make decisions. That's how presidents work.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoHacking government and hacking software are different things. You can't offer TCP/IP $100M to leak you some private keys from the server. The smaller the government, the more value you could get per bribe (more power located in individuals) and the easier it would be to do it (smaller governments presumably lack layers of security measures against bribery). In case of extremely small government a big corporation could buy it out entirely.
- madaxe 13y agoThe majority of troops on the ground in Iraq and Afghanistan were not US Military - predominantly PMCs - so I don't think it's correct to say that corporations do not have the capability to wage real, physical war.
- jacques_chester 13y agoSubcontracting your monopoly is still a monopoly.
- pyre 13y agoPMCs are allowed to operate because the government allows them to operate.
- mcguire 13y agoAt some point, however, that statement reverses itself.
- chris_j 13y agoWould you mind spelling out what is meant by "PMC"s?
- madaxe 13y agoPrivate military contractor.
- retroafroman 13y ago>The majority of troops on the ground in Iraq and Afghanistan were not US Military - predominantly PMCs Citation please. I don't believe this to be true based on first hand accounts of people who have been to both of those places.
- madaxe 13y agoBelieve whatever you want. Objective facts don't cars for you. http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/06/29/256726/afghanistan-contractors-surge/?mobile=wp http://thinkprogress.org/security/2011/06/29/256726/afghanis...
- philwelch 13y ago> Of course he would. Big corporations can buy things and sell things, but they can't legally send out men with guns and dogs to simply take what they decide they need. Well, sure, because we have a government to stop them.
- pyre 13y agoThe government doesn't need to be encroaching on being a totalitarian regime to keep 'big corporations' in check.
- yxhuvud 13y agoWell, it is not very common for them to do that anymore, anyway. There are plenty of counterexamples if we allow historical examples. The East India Company being the biggest and most obvious example.