18 ms·
If you do not support a person's right to express an opinion that you abhor you do not support free speech at all. I support their right to express it. I also
by swombat 18y ago
If you do not support a person's right to express an opinion that you abhor you do not support free speech at all.
I support their right to express it. I also support Facebook's right to remove them from the virtual, private premises for expressing it. I also support their right to complain that Facebook deleted their account because they were expressing hate-speech. I also support our collective right to side with Facebook on this one.
- absconditus 18y agoI support Facebook's right to censor them as well. I would not agree with their decision to do so, but it is their decision to make. I write this not because I agree with Holocaust deniers. What if the issue were a 9/11 conspiracy theorist group? A group that discusses differences in intelligence between ethnic groups?
- swombat 18y agoWhat if the issue were a 9/11 conspiracy theorist group? Then I would not support their removal. I don't have any credible evidence that 9/11 truthers are rooting for mass murder on a global scale, so I believe they're harmless.
- absconditus 18y agoI realized that this wasn't a good example after reading your comment a second time. I added an additional example moments later. Facebook is free to shape their community in any manner they see fit. If their goal is simply to have the largest audience possible then perhaps being overly political correct serves their purposes well. I happen to believe that a community is much more interesting when distasteful views are not censored. I'd much rather give users the option to suppress groups that they do not wish to see.
- absconditus 18y agoDo you also agree that Google has the same rights to censor their search results in a similar manner? Would you agree with a decision to suppress results which lead to "hate speech" websites?
- swombat 18y agoThere are some significant differences between Facebook and Google. We're not talking about hosting or removing pointers to information, we're talking about hosting discussion. I would fully support Google's right to remove any discussion they don't like from any forums where they host discussion. I think making something disappear from the search results would be a little more delicate, particularly since Google are currently in a quasi-monopoly situation, but I would, on the whole, support their right to block search results that they want to block, yes.
- thenduks 18y agoI also support Facebook's right to remove them from the virtual, private premises for expressing it. And Facebook has decided that it will not remove them. Issue closed. They've made their position pretty clear.