4 ms·
The question I have is this: will they be able to get rid of all these damn remotes I have to deal with? Every device (projector, receiver, cable box, video swi
by chongli 13y ago
The question I have is this: will they be able to get rid of all these damn remotes I have to deal with? Every device (projector, receiver, cable box, video switcher...) has its own damn remote!
Oh, and before anyone asks: yes I've tried those fancy universal remotes. The problem with all of them is that power buttons for most devices act as toggles and there's no way for the universal remote to know which devices are on and which are off. This leads to annoying situations where some devices are getting switched on and others off every time I hit the power button!
- untog 13y agoI'm mostly just amazed at how much universal remotes cost. I cannot fathom paying $250 for a remote control: https://www.google.com/shopping/product/7778030267502985797 https://www.google.com/shopping/product/7778030267502985797 In answer to your question: no, it probably won't. The HDMI standard does have an option for passing through power signals though, so it's possible that the next cable box, receiver and TV will all obey that signal.
- mikestew 13y agoThe $300 I spent on a Logitech Harmony remote was worth every...damned...penny. Maybe your spouse/SO doesn't come to you because they can't figure out which combination of three remotes it takes to watch Netflix or play a game. Mine used to. And frankly, there's no reason she should have to do either one: come to me or figure out the incantation. I can figure it out, but I don't think I should have to, either. Nor should I have to keep four remotes lying around. I push "watch TV" and it casts the spell to use the Apple TV. "Play Xbox", and it switches everything around without fiddling. Gestures? Color me really, really skeptical that this will improve upon what I've got now.
- finnh 13y agoWOW. The Harmony One has doubled in price since I bought my (two) in late 2010 for $159.99. Now that I've moved houses I've got a spare one in the basement. I guess it's time to craigslist that bad boy.
- stx331 13y agoThat is the same exact remote I own, it can use basic functions on almost any TV without the need to program, the shenanigans that occur in my house..
- Joeri 13y agoKeep an eye on logitech's special offers section. I got a harmony at 70% off. http://www.logitech.com/en-us/special-offers http://www.logitech.com/en-us/special-offers
- mikestew 13y agoThe remote (at least the Logitech Harmony) knows the state in which it last left the device. If that somehow gets toggled (it happens rarely at my house), there's a "help" button that basically toggles through the power states until you say "yeah, that fixed it". You can toggle the device yourself, obviously, but it's a good feature for the less technical in the house.
- Joeri 13y agoI have one of those, and i end up operating the devices directly a lot of the time because it gets hopelessly confused by the matrix of power and input states (admittedly, i have a terrible combination of devices with auto-input switching and power toggling). And the whole line of sight thing is really annoying when you've got a 2 year old running in front of the tv during a complex 20 second multidevice sequence. My dad went one better, with infrared transmitters taped on the devices operated by wire from a base station with a wifi-based remote. Even that gets confused from time to time, despite literally days of trying to get the timing right. Until the device makers start cooperating reliable universal remotes are impossible.