5 ms·
To offer an opposing view: I cannot be coerced into revealing that information, even under torture. That is a huge claim. I do not imagine that his training i
by untog 13y ago
To offer an opposing view:
I cannot be coerced into revealing that information, even under torture.
That is a huge claim. I do not imagine that his training involved being tortured to make sure. If he's wrong, there could be dire consequences for the US.
You might even say his ego is writing checks his body can't cash.
- ianterrell 13y agoI interpret this as it's protected in such a way that any information he can give is not sufficient to access the documents. (copy pasted from my reply on another comment below)
- pkfrank 13y agoAgreed. The specificity of his claim seems to support that, as well: >I cannot be coerced... vs. "won't", "would never", et. al.
- brown9-2 13y agoHow would that work though? Wouldn't it mean that in order to access the info he is talking about, you need something more than knowledge he has in his head - like physical access to something? But then, in the worst case scenario - how could Snowden access it himself if he needs the documents?
- lifeformed 13y agoPerhaps it's more of a way to destroy data than to not reveal it, like maybe some sort of dead-man's switch. If he doesn't maintain some routine, then perhaps some data or documents gets automatically destroyed.
- dantheman 13y agoA very simple way to achieve something like this is to generate a random password, print it out and give half to someone else. Then you need 2 people to access the file.
- brown9-2 13y agoPerhaps there are scenarios I am not thinking of then but then in order to access the documents/information, he would need to be able to freely communicate with the other party. If he was to be detained somewhere without outside contact the world, then how can the info be disseminated to fulfill his threat?
- lightbritefight 13y agoA verbal agreement akin to a killswitch. No verifiable contact by august 5th? Info dump to pastebin. Resets every two weeks.
- jmathai 13y agoIt doesn't then take much torture to extract the other person's name. Then a little more torture for the other party to get the missing piece of the puzzle.
- fragsworth 13y agoIf those people are in different countries (e.g. one in the U.S. and one in China) then it is not possible to get them.
- jeltz 13y agoEspecially not if he also has a killswitch which will go off once he disappears. The question is if said killswitch exists will it release the data or destroy it?
- jessaustin 13y agoWhy would he know their name? Why wouldn't they have a similar group of people-switches arranged in a hierarchy?
- lessnonymous 13y agoThis is my belief. Spread the password and access details to two people without keeping it yourself. Those two people split their in half without keeping it themselves. The four people who now have the password are the 'kill switch' required to monitor Snowden's location. Snowden has no idea who they are. Should he be tortured, all he can do is reveal his first two contacts. The torturer will now have to abduct those two people to get the key. All these second level people know is the two people THEY spoke to. So you need BOTH of the second level to get all four of the third level people. And then you'll have to abduct another FOUR people to get the key. All before these four people realize Snoden has disappeared. He knows he can't resist torture. But he doesn't have to. He LITERALLY cannot be coerced.
- 6d0debc071 13y agoBut then... why wouldn't he say that more precisely? If I had my documents encrypted with keys that I'd distributed to multiple parties, I'd be shouting it from the rooftops: "No point torturing me, the key is in three pieces and if I don't sign in every week the data will be destroyed so realistically you can't possibly seize all the pieces in the time-frame you'd require! Of course, if you can get all the pieces, just stick us all together in the same room and I promise to give you my piece, so no point torturing me then either." Seems like there'd be a really strong incentive to have people know you had a mechanism that ensured it.
- sigzero 13y agoSnowden is FULL of crap.
- peterkelly 13y agoCould you explain why?
- BWStearns 13y agoDue to the specificity of his claims. Also he was probably very reasonably paranoid during the prep phase of this whole fiasco. Coercion is not an unreasonable expectation for someone in his position and he has the technical chops to implement such a failsafe. I cannot imagine that anyone in his situation with a modicum of technical savvy would simply carry around data that one could be forced to decrypt.
- wavefunction 13y agoI wouldn't hold your breath. sigzero is not a fan of Snowden, as can be deduced from his other posts on this subject.
- btipling 13y agoI think he probably means he has a distress password that will destroy his encrypted data if he was put under duress to disclose anything. I don't believe he is saying he can withstand pain indefinitely.
- marshray 13y agoSeems like anyone with a clue would have made a raw copy of the data before applying the password. Assuming the raw media is physically accessible to them, that is. Hmmm....
- btbuildem 13y agoI think he may be hinting that he does not hold the key to the information, perhaps multiple keys are required, or the nature of the key is such that it cannot be reproduced under duress, etc etc.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- peter487 13y agoHe is probably using some encryption technique which requires multiple keys to unlock, perhaps similar to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir%27s_Secret_Sharing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir%27s_Secret_Sharing
- Osmium 13y agoMaybe his information is encrypted such that it requires multiple parties to decrypt; i.e. his consent is a necessary but not a sufficient condition to decrypt his data, so that it wouldn't be revealed even under torture. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secret_sharing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secret_sharing
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 13y agoYou can make a process where you breaking down and cooperating with the enemy is not enough to reveal the info.
- phaus 13y agoSuch training does not exist anywhere on this planet. Edit: I already mentioned SERE training in a higher level post. It's pretty intense, but still, the most valuable lesson you learn is that everyone will end up talking. I was simply commenting on the possibility of a person resisting torture. If that person has some sort of safety mechanism in place, the torturer might not be able to get the information he wants, but that's not because the victim has resisted, because he won't.
- lifeformed 13y agoThe training is right here: 1) Write some software that destroys your data if you don't login every x hours. 2) Under duress, stall for x hours.
- phaus 13y agoIf they abduct and torture you immediately, the chances of you stalling for x hours is pretty much non-existent. Snowden is in Russia. Arguably, no nation on the planet is better at torturing people than they are, and unlike the U.S. Russia doesn't really give a shit if the rest of the world doesn't like their methods. His interrogation would likely take minutes, not hours.
- lifeformed 13y agoWell, my point is that there are alternate ways of ensuring the data doesn't get out, not just by being really good at resisting torture. Other methods: A) Alternate password that destroys the data. B) Cyanide capsule in tooth.
- shabble 13y agoMany US military personnel go through SERE[1] training, which includes some rather unpleasant things, and other countries have similar programs (The UK RTI[2] for one example). Obviously a group less concerned about the long-term health of their interrogatees have a lot more flexibility in methods, and training is largely understood to be a delaying tactic to spoil time-sentitive tactical data, rather than resist interrogation indefinitely. Hypothetically, there could be a mechanism by which he has to check in with some associates periodically, who by means of some N of M secret sharing are able to destroy/release the data otherwise. Then you need to resist for only 1-2 checkin periods. Or have a duress codeword that causes the same result. Any destruction scheme requires that the data be held somewhere secure enough not to be cloned though. (And any heartbeat type scheme requires periodic communication with some/all associates, possibly leading your adversary to them, although broadcast media is probably good enough while he's mainstream news) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survival,_Evasion,_Resistance_and_Escape https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survival,_Evasion,_Resistance_... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resistance_to_interrogation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resistance_to_interrogation